Learning outcomes
By the end of this lesson you should be able to: state the red flags that separate a tumour from infection, injury or arthritis; describe the classic patient, site and radiographic appearance of the common benign bone lesions; describe the two commonest primary malignant bone tumours and their radiographic signatures; explain the significance of a metastasis or myeloma in a patient over 40 with a destructive bone lesion; describe the approach to investigating an undiagnosed bone lesion; and state the principles of biopsy and of surgical treatment of a malignant bone tumour.
Prerequisites
Lesson 1 (Fractures & dislocations) — including pathological fractures — and Lesson 7 (bone infection, which is the main differential). No oncology is assumed.
The big idea
The single question that separates a bone tumour from everything else in musculoskeletal disease is time. Infection declares itself over days, a fracture over seconds, arthritis over months with the whole joint involved. A tumour grows over months, produces pain that is constant rather than activity-related, and produces a mass that the patient can feel. When a patient says that the pain is present at rest, wakes them at night, and has nothing to do with what they have been doing, the tumour box has been ticked and it is your job to exclude it.
| Feature | Tumour | Infection | Injury |
|---|---|---|---|
| Duration | Weeks to months of steadily worsening pain | Days, with a febrile illness | Immediate, after an event |
| Pain character | Constant, boring, night pain, unrelated to activity | Constant, throbbing and severe, with a fever | Sharp at the moment, then related to movement |
| Systemic features | Weight loss in a malignancy; otherwise well | Fever, malaise and anorexia; raised CRP and WCC | None |
| Mass | A growing mass that the patient may have noticed | Swelling is hot, red and tender | Swelling is soft-tissue haematoma |
| Inflammatory markers | Normal (or a mildly raised ALP) | Raised CRP, ESR and WCC | Normal |
Watch outThe four red flags to quote and never to dismiss: night pain that wakes the patient; pain that is constant and unrelated to activity; a palpable, enlarging mass; and a pathological fracture after a trivial mechanism. Any one of them, in a patient over 40, means you are looking for a metastasis or a myeloma before you are looking for anything else.
Benign bone lesions
| Lesion | Age and site | Radiograph | Clinical point |
|---|---|---|---|
| Simple (unicameral) bone cyst | Children and adolescents; the proximal humerus and proximal femur | A well-defined central lytic lesion in the metaphysis, expanding the cortex thinly, with a fallen fragment sign after a fracture | Often presents as a pathological fracture; heals at skeletal maturity; injection or curettage if symptomatic |
| Aneurysmal bone cyst | Under 20; the metaphysis of a long bone or the spine | An eccentric, expansile, 'blow-out' lytic lesion with a thin cortical shell and fluid levels on MRI | Grows aggressively and can be mistaken for a malignancy; treated by curettage and grafting |
| Fibrous cortical defect / non-ossifying fibroma | Children; the distal femur and distal tibia | A small eccentric cortical scallop with a sclerotic rim | Common, incidental and self-limiting — it ossifies and disappears |
| Osteochondroma (exostosis) | Adolescents; a bony outgrowth from the metaphysis, capped with cartilage | A pedunculated or sessile exostosis continuous with the cortex and medulla | Hereditary multiple exostoses when many; the risk is a malignant change (< 1%) heralded by pain and a growing cartilage cap |
| Enchondroma | Any age; the small bones of the hand and feet | A central lytic lesion with chondroid ring-and-arc calcification | Benign but must be watched in a long bone or the pelvis; multiple in Ollier's disease / Maffucci's syndrome |
| Giant cell tumour (osteoclastoma) | 20-40 years; the epiphysis of a long bone, abutting the joint, around the knee | A purely lytic, expansile epiphyseal lesion reaching the articular surface | Locally aggressive; complete curettage and grafting or a wide excision; recurs and can metastasise to the lung |
| Osteoid osteoma | Children and young men; the cortex of a long bone, the femoral neck, the spine | A small radiolucent nidus under 1.5 cm with dense surrounding sclerosis | Night pain relieved dramatically by NSAIDs; treated by radiofrequency ablation or excision |
NoteThree 'shortcuts' that are worth memorising. Location tells you the lesion: a cyst is central and metaphyseal, a giant cell tumour is epiphyseal and reaches the joint, a fibrous cortical defect is eccentric and cortical. Shape tells you the behaviour: a well-defined sclerotic rim is benign and slow, an ill-defined permeative margin is aggressive and malignant. Age tells you the age: a lesion in the young is more likely benign; a lesion after 40 is more likely a metastasis.
Malignant bone tumours
| Osteosarcoma | Ewing's sarcoma | |
|---|---|---|
| Cell of origin | Bone-forming (mesenchymal) cells producing osteoid | A primitive neuroectodermal cell, of uncertain lineage |
| Typical age | 10-25 years, around the growth spurt | 5-15 years, in the first two decades |
| Typical site | Metaphysis of a long bone: distal femur, proximal tibia, proximal humerus | Diaphysis of a long bone, and the flat bones of the pelvis and chest wall |
| Radiograph | A destructive metaphyseal lesion with mixed sclerosis and lysis, a Codman triangle (periosteum lifted at the margin), sunburst spiculation, cortical destruction and a soft-tissue mass with ossification | A permeative, 'moth-eaten' medullary lesion in a diaphysis with an onion-skin (lamellated) periosteal reaction and a large soft-tissue mass |
| The serum marker | Alkaline phosphatase raised in proportion to the tumour burden; a normal value after successful treatment is reassuring, and a rising one suggests recurrence | LDH often raised; the EWSR1-FLI1 (or ERG) translocation is the molecular signature |
| Metastases | Lungs, bone, and rarely skip lesions in the same bone; 80% of patients present without visible metastasis | Lungs, bone and marrow; the marrow involvement is why bone marrow biopsy is done |
| Treatment | Neoadjuvant chemotherapy, wide surgical resection (limb-salvage where possible), then adjuvant chemotherapy; radiotherapy is only for unresectable or residual disease | Chemotherapy is the mainstay (the tumour is highly radiosensitive), plus local control by surgery or radiotherapy; radiotherapy is much more central than in osteosarcoma |
Watch outThe classic trap is treating the first symptom. A teenager with a painful knee and a radiographic 'knee injury' has sometimes been treated for months with physiotherapy before someone radiographs the femur — and the osteosarcoma in the distal femoral metaphysis has been growing the whole time. Any young patient with persistent, unexplained, night-time bone pain needs a radiograph of the site of the pain, not of the knee that hurts.
After 40, the arithmetic changes completely. In a patient over forty with a destructive bone lesion, the diagnosis is a metastasis or myeloma until proven otherwise — primary bone sarcoma in that age group is rare, and a 'bone scan-plus-long-bone-series' work-up comes before any discussion of a primary bone tumour.
| Tumour | Patient and site | Clinical signature |
|---|---|---|
| Metastatic carcinoma | Any adult, more often over 40; the axial skeleton, the proximal femur, the humerus and the ribs — anywhere there is red marrow | Pain, a pathological fracture, and sometimes a raised calcium or alkaline phosphatase. The commonest tumours that metastasise to bone are breast, prostate, lung, kidney and thyroid. A lytic lesion in the proximal femur with a fracture is the classic presentation |
| Multiple myeloma | A patient over 50, more often men; the spine, ribs, skull, pelvis and proximal femur | Bone pain, anaemia, renal impairment, hypercalcaemia, recurrent infections and 'punched-out' lytic lesions with no sclerosis — and a normal alkaline phosphatase. Diagnosed on serum protein electrophoresis, a monoclonal band, and marrow biopsy |
| Chondrosarcoma | Middle-aged and older adults; the pelvis, the shoulder girdle, the proximal femur | A slowly expanding cartilaginous tumour with ring-and-arc calcification, a bulky soft-tissue mass, and pain; treated by wide resection because it is not chemosensitive or radiosensitive |
| Chordoma | Adults; the sacrum and the clivus (the residual notochord) | A midline lesion in the sacrum with bladder and bowel symptoms, or in the clivus with cranial nerve palsies; slowly growing and locally destructive |
NoteThe 'blastic and sclerotic' lesion is not always prostate cancer, and the 'purely lytic with no sclerosis and a normal alkaline phosphatase' lesion is not always a myeloma — but they are both worth knowing as the rule rather than the exception. Prostate metastases are osteoblastic; breast, kidney, thyroid and lung metastases are typically lytic; myeloma produces purely lytic lesions with no reactive sclerosis and does not raise alkaline phosphatase, because the tumour is not forming bone.
Investigating a bone lesion
The order of investigation is principled and even a junior should be able to justify it. Radiograph first, because it is cheap and gives the pattern; then MRI, which defines the marrow and soft-tissue extent; then CT for cortical detail and for the chest in a malignancy; then a bone scan for the whole skeleton and for skip lesions; then, and only then, a biopsy.
| Investigation | What it tells you | The rule |
|---|---|---|
| Plain radiographs in two planes | The site (central/eccentric, metaphyseal/epiphyseal/diaphyseal), the pattern of destruction (geographic, moth-eaten, permeative), matrix mineralisation, and the periosteal reaction | Always the first image, and always two views at right angles |
| MRI | The intramedullary extent, the soft-tissue mass, the relationship to the neurovascular bundle and the joint line — everything that determines whether the limb can be saved | The staging investigation of a malignant bone tumour |
| CT | Cortical breach, the matrix, and particularly the lungs and the mediastinum for metastasis | CT chest for staging; CT pelvis for a lesion the MRI cannot resolve |
| Whole-body bone scan (isotope bone scan) | Skeletal multplicity and skip lesions | Once a malignant bone tumour is suspected, before biopsy |
| PET-CT | Metabolic activity, systemic extent and treatment response | Increasingly used for both staging and response assessment |
Watch outThe biopsy is the last step, and it is planned as if it were the first part of the operation. A poorly placed biopsy track can seed a tract that must later be excised with the tumour, and a badly planned biopsy can contaminate a compartment that could have been resected safely. It is done by the surgeon who will do the resection, through the muscle that will be resected with the tumour, and never in a longitudinal incision that sends the track through the joint. Do not biopsy before the imaging is complete and before the referral has been made — a biopsy done in a district hospital has ended more limb-salvage attempts than radiation has.
Pathological fracture
NoteThe practical sequence in an older patient with a fracture of the proximal femur after a trivial fall: the fracture is fixed (that is the immediate problem), and the question 'why did this bone break?' is asked afterwards. A lesion that is clearly lytic on the film, or a fracture at a site with no explanation for the mechanism, warrants oncological staging — and the more common answer in the elderly is a metastasis, not a myeloma or a primary bone tumour.
Common mistakes
Watch outAttributing night pain to a 'sprain' or to growing pain. Growing pain is bilateral, in the evening, and has a normal examination. Nocturnal pain in a limb that is worse at night, constant, and unrelated to activity is a red flag for a bone tumour, and a radiograph of the site is the minimum response. It is the single most commonly missed serious diagnosis in paediatric orthopaedics.
Watch outReading the lytic lesion as one or the other. A lytic, mildly expansile lesion with ring-and-arc calcification is a cartilage lesion (enchondroma or chondrosarcoma); a purely lytic lesion with no sclerosis in a patient over 50 with anaemia and renal impairment is a myeloma; a lytic lesion in a patient with a known primary is a metastasis; a sclerotic lesion with sunburst spiculation in a teenager is an osteosarcoma. The matrix is the message.
Watch outBiopsying a potentially malignant bone lesion before the imaging is complete, or by the wrong route. Stage the lesion, then biopsy through the muscle that will be resected, by the surgeon doing the resection. A badly planned biopsy has ended more limb-salvage attempts than a late diagnosis has.
Watch outAssuming that a normal alkaline phosphatase excludes malignancy, or that a raised alkaline phosphatase proves malignancy. Alkaline phosphatase is raised in osteosarcoma and in Paget's disease, in osteoblastic metastases, and in growing children; it is normal in myeloma, because the plasma cell does not make bone. It is one data point in a differential that includes many.
Check your understanding
Name the red flags that separate a bone tumour from infection, injury or arthritis.
How does the radiographic appearance of an osteosarcoma differ from that of a Ewing's sarcoma?
A 62-year-old with a known breast carcinoma and new pain over the proximal femur has a lytic lesion in the lesser trochanter. What is the likely diagnosis, and what are the two things you do?
Multiple choice
A 15-year-old boy has progressive distal thigh pain with a tender mass and raised alkaline phosphatase; the radiograph shows a destructive metaphyseal lesion with a Codman triangle and sunburst spiculation. Which is the most likely diagnosis?
Which statement about the primary management of a suspected osteosarcoma is correct?
Which single feature most strongly distinguishes a bone tumour from acute pyogenic osteomyelitis?