Learning outcomes
By the end of this lesson you should be able to: describe the normal sagittal curves and define kyphosis, lordosis and scoliosis; distinguish structural from non-structural scoliosis at the bedside using the forward-bend test; describe the classification of adolescent idiopathic scoliosis (right thoracic, the Risser scale and curve magnitude) and say when observation, bracing and surgery are indicated; describe the clinical features and management of spondylolisthesis and spondylolysis; explain the red flags of back pain and the categories of differential; and outline the assessment, imaging choice and management of the adult with back pain.
Prerequisites
Lessons 1-2 (fractures and their complications) and Lesson 9 (bone tumours, which is the differential for a destructive spinal lesion). From Gross Anatomy I: the vertebrae, the intervertebral disc, the facet joints and the spinal cord.
The big idea
The spine is a series of curves that balance each other, and spinal deformity is a disturbance of that balance. In the sagittal plane the curves alternate: the thoracic spine is kyphotic and the cervical and lumbar spines are lordotic, and the sum of the curves keeps the head and the trunk centred over the pelvis. In the coronal plane the spine is straight. When a curve appears in the wrong plane, or a curve in the right plane becomes too large, the whole balance must correct somewhere else — and it is that correction, more than the curve itself, that produces the symptoms.
| Curve | Normal | Too much | Too little |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cervical and lumbar (lordosis) | Concave posteriorly — the convexity faces anteriorly | Hyperlordosis — a swayback; from obesity, a spondylolisthesis, a fixed hip flexion contracture, or a compensation for a thoracic kyphosis | A flat back, from spasm or a rigid posture |
| Thoracic (kyphosis) | Convex posteriorly, between 20° and 45° | Hyperkyphosis ('round back'); from Scheuermann's disease, a compression fracture, ankylosing spondylitis, or tuberculosis (Pott's kyphosis) | Reduced or reversed kyphosis (flat back) |
| Either (scoliosis) | Straight in the coronal plane | Lateral curvature of more than 10°, with rotation of the vertebral bodies | — |
Scoliosis
The first clinical question is always whether the curve is structural. A structural curve is fixed: it does not correct when the patient is made to bend, and it rotates. A non-structural (postural) curve corrects completely on forward bending and on side-lying or traction, and has no rotation. The reason they are distinguished at the bedside is that the structural one is the disease and the postural one is only a habit.
| Type of scoliosis | Proportion | Cause and pattern |
|---|---|---|
| Adolescent idiopathic (AIS) | About 80% of all scoliosis | A structural curve of unknown cause, appearing at or just after the onset of the pubertal growth spurt; much commoner in girls, and the progressive thoracic curve needing treatment is 8-10 times commoner in girls |
| Neuromuscular | The next commonest group | Cerebral palsy, muscular dystrophy, spina bifida, poliomyelitis, spinal muscular atrophy: paralysis and spasticity produce a long, C-shaped curve that progresses throughout growth and often continues after growth ends |
| Congenital | A small proportion | A failure of formation (hemivertebra, wedge vertebra) or a failure of segmentation (unsegmented bar, block vertebra); present at birth and diagnosed on radiographs in a child with an asymmetry noticed by the parents |
| Syndromic / postural / compensatory | A small proportion | Neurofibromatosis, Marfan's syndrome, a limb-length discrepancy (a non-structural curve that corrects when the pelvis is levelled), and a painful scoliosis that demands a search for a cause (a tumour, infection or an osteoid osteoma) |
Watch outA structural scoliosis that is painful, that is progressing rapidly, that is left-sided (a right thoracic curve is the rule; a left thoracic curve is the exception), or that is associated with any neurological sign, is not adolescent idiopathic scoliosis until it has been investigated. A painful curve with normal radiographs in a child is an osteoid osteoma or an infection until proven otherwise — imaging, including MRI of the whole spine, comes before any bracing decision.
The assessment of a structural curve is in three parts. Look at the whole spine in the coronal plane, with the pelvis levelled and the patient undressed, measuring the rib hump and the shoulder asymmetry. Then bend the patient forward to distinguish structural from non-structural, and assess rotation. Then image, and measure by the Cobb method: the angle between the upper end plate of the uppermost vertebra and the lower end plate of the lowermost vertebra of the curve.
| Curve magnitude and maturity | Management |
|---|---|
| Under 20-25°, in a patient at or near skeletal maturity (Risser 4-5) | Observation with serial clinical and radiographic reviews; most curves under 25° do not progress in a mature patient |
| 20-25° with growth remaining, or a curve that progresses by 5° or more between visits | Bracing — a thoracolumbosacral orthosis, worn until maturity, to prevent progression rather than to correct the curve |
| Over 45-50° in a skeletally mature patient, or a progressive curve over 45° in a growing one | Surgical correction and fusion — because a curve of 50° or more continues to progress slowly through adult life and carries the cosmetic and the functional consequences of an untreated deformity |
| Any curve with a neurological deficit, or a curve with an identified cause | Investigate and treat the cause; instrumentation and fusion as indicated |
NoteThe examinable number: a right thoracic curve of about 30° in a pre-menarchal girl at Risser 1 with a persistent rib hump that does not correct on side-bending is an indication for a brace — the curve has growth left to grow into, and bracing stops it. Bracing does not straighten the spine; it holds the curve where it is until growth finishes, and its success depends almost entirely on the hours a day the brace is actually worn.
A 13-year-old girl has a right thoracic curve of 30° with a prominent rib hump on forward bending. On side-bending radiographs the curve does not correct. What is the next step in her management and what are you trying to prevent?
Spondylolysis and spondylolisthesis
| Aspect | Spondylolysis | Spondylolisthesis |
|---|---|---|
| Patient | An adolescent athlete — a gymnast, fast bowler, dancer or rower; a young adult with hyperextension activities | Any age; the adolescent with a pars defect, and the adult with degenerative facet arthrosis that permits slippage |
| Symptoms | Deep low back pain, worse on extension and relieved by flexion; the classic history is pain that is worse in the standing phases of the sport | Back pain radiating to the buttocks and thighs, and in the higher grades to the legs, with a 'slipping' sensation on walking |
| Signs | Pain on extension of the spine; a step in the spinous processes in the higher grades | A palpable step, a shortened gluteal contour, and in the severe case a radicular or cauda equina picture |
| Radiographs | A 'Scotty dog with a collar' appearance on the oblique view, with the pars defect as a break in the neck | The forward slip is visible on the lateral view; flexion-extension views detect the instability that determines the treatment |
NoteThe treatment of a spondylolysis in a young athlete is non-operative in most cases: activity modification, a flexion-based rehabilitation programme, and physiotherapy for the core and the gluteals. The treatment of a slip of grade III or more, or a slip that is progressing, or one with a neurological deficit, is surgical — decompression and instrumented fusion. The grading matters because slips of grade I-II with a stable, non-progressive pattern almost never need surgery.
Back pain and the differential
Back pain is the commonest musculoskeletal symptom and the one where the differential is the whole job. Mechanical back pain — from disc degeneration, facet joints, muscle and ligament — accounts for over 90% of it, and the red flags are the small group that identifies the rest.
| Red flag | What you are looking for | The action |
|---|---|---|
| Age under 20 or over 50 at first onset | A tumour, an infection or an inflammatory condition | Radiograph, inflammatory markers, and consider MRI |
| Weight loss, fever or night sweats | M tuberculosis, malignancy, or sepsis | Inflammatory markers, MRI of the whole spine, cultures |
| Bladder or bowel dysfunction, saddle anaesthesia | Cauda equina syndrome — a surgical emergency | Immediate MRI and neurosurgical referral for decompression |
| Progressive neurological deficit in the legs | A structural (neoplastic, compressive or infective) lesion | MRI and urgent referral |
| A history of malignancy, or a night-time pain unrelieved by rest | Metastasis or a primary bone tumour | Radiograph, MRI, bone scan and chest imaging |
| Morning stiffness for over 30 minutes, improving with exercise | An inflammatory spondyloarthropathy (ankylosing spondylitis) | HLA-B27, inflammatory markers, sacroiliac joint imaging |
| Pain after significant trauma, or in an osteoporotic patient on steroids | A vertebral compression fracture | Radiograph, and MRI if the pain is out of proportion or persists |
Watch outCauda equina syndrome is the emergency. A patient with back pain who also has urinary retention or overflow incontinence, faecal incontinence, bilateral leg pain or weakness, or numbness in the saddle, perineal or genital distribution needs an MRI immediately and decompression within hours. Bladder function is the treatment deadline: incontinence or retention is irreversible if decompression is delayed, and the history from the patient is taken seriously even when the anal tone is normal on the first attempt.
| Differential of back pain | Distinguishing feature |
|---|---|
| Mechanical / degenerative disc and facet disease | A history of loading-related pain, worse with activity and better at rest, no red flags, and no neurological deficit |
| Disc herniation with radiculopathy | Leg pain below the knee, in a dermatomal pattern, with a positive straight-leg raise test (radicular, not back, pain is the dominant symptom) |
| Spinal infection (vertebral osteomyelitis or discitis) | Fever, raised inflammatory markers, night pain, and a high index of suspicion in the immunosuppressed, the diabetic and the intravenous drug user |
| Malignancy (metastasis, myeloma, lymphoma) | A history of malignancy, weight loss, night pain, and a raised protein or immunoparesis on blood tests |
| Inflammatory (ankylosing spondylitis and the spondyloarthropathies) | Morning stiffness over 30 minutes, improvement with exercise, and involvement of the spine and the sacroiliac joints |
| Referred visceral pain | Pain unaffected by spinal posture, with abdominal, pelvic or urological findings that explain it |
Common mistakes
Watch outTreating a curve as structural because it looks curved. Only the forward bend test tells you: a structural curve persists and rotates on forward bending; a non-structural curve flattens. This distinction is also what separates a limb-length discrepancy that will be treated by a shoe raise from a scoliosis that needs a brace.
Watch outFailing to look for a cause in an atypical scoliosis. Pain, a left-sided curve, rapid progression, an abnormal neurological examination or absence of a thoracic curve in an adolescent are all indications for an MRI before any treatment decision. A structural scoliosis with pain in a child is an osteoid osteoma until proven otherwise.
Watch outDismissing back pain in a patient with a history of cancer as mechanical. Night pain, a known primary and weight loss require radiographs and, in most cases, MRI — and a destructive vertebral lesion in a patient with a known carcinoma is a metastasis until proven otherwise.
Watch outMissing a cauda equina syndrome because the first examination of the perineal sensation was normal. Ask about bladder and bowel function directly, examine the saddle area, and repeat it. Incontinence is a late and partly irreversible sign, and decompression has to happen before it, not after it.
Check your understanding
How do you distinguish structural from non-structural scoliosis at the bedside, and why does it matter?
State the treatment thresholds for adolescent idiopathic scoliosis.
List six red flags in a patient with back pain, and the investigation each demands.
Multiple choice
A pre-menarchal 13-year-old girl (Risser 1) has a 30° right thoracic curve; the rib hump persists on forward bending and does not correct on side-bending. What is the most appropriate management?
Which combination of findings is most consistent with a structural scoliosis?
Which statement about spondylolisthesis is correct?