Learning outcomes
By the end of this lesson you should be able to: describe how tuberculosis spread to the spine and why it is a disease of paradiscal bone and skip lesions; recognise the clinical picture of Pott's disease — the insidious back pain, the night sweats, the constitutional symptoms and the cold abscess; describe the stages of radiographic destruction and the collapse that produces the kyphosis; list the neurological complications, in particular the difference between early- and late-onset paraplegia; state the principles of anti-tuberculous chemotherapy and the indications for surgical decompression and stabilisation; and explain the mechanism of poliomyelitis, the residual deformities it leaves, and the orthotic and surgical principles of its management.
Prerequisites
Lesson 1 (Fractures & dislocations) and Lesson 7 (bone infection). You need the vertebrae and the spinal cord, the segmental innervation of the limbs, and the muscle groups tested at each level, from Gross Anatomy I.
The big idea
Tuberculosis of bone teaches you a lesson about the difference between infection in bone and infection in a joint. Suppurative osteomyelitis is hot, fast and destructive within days, raising inflammatory markers and producing pus; tuberculous infection is cold, slow and indolent, raising them barely or not at all, producing caseous material rather than frank pus, and taking months to declare itself. That is why the diagnosis is made late, and why the patient presents with a deformity rather than with a fever.
NoteTwo words are the examinable core of this lesson. 'Paradiscal' — the infection starts in the anterior vertebral body next to the disc, and the disc is involved early, which distinguishes it from a pyogenic infection of bone, where the disc is resistant and involved late. 'Cold' — the abscess is not hot, red or tender, and it tracks along tissue planes to appear far from its source, which is why a psoas abscess points in the thigh.
How tuberculous infection reaches the spine
The portal is almost always haematogenous, from a pulmonary (or occasionally gastrointestinal or genitourinary) focus, and the organism lodges in the highly vascular cancellous bone of the vertebral body. The pattern that follows has a predictable anatomy.
| Pattern | Where the infection starts | What it destroys |
|---|---|---|
| Paradiscal (commonest) | The anterior part of the vertebral body adjacent to the intervertebral disc | The disc space is destroyed early and the infection crosses into the next vertebra — contiguous involvement of two or more vertebrae with relative disc destruction early |
| Central | The centre of the vertebral body | The body may collapse concentrically and be flattened into a vertebra plana, or balloon out |
| Anterior | The anterior surface of the body beneath the periosteum | Multiple levels may be involved in a skip pattern, with the discs relatively spared at first |
| Posterior | The posterior elements — the pedicles, laminae and facets | The neural arch is involved, so paraplegia can occur without the gross vertebral-body destruction of the other patterns; the pattern that is missed most often |
| Appendiceal | The transverse or spinous process | A rare pattern, and a source of diagnostic confusion |
The word 'cold' explains the path. Caseous material tracks along tissue planes with little reaction at its border, so infection from the dorsolumbar spine enters the psoas sheath and produces a psoas abscess that points below the inguinal ligament and appears as a lump in the groin or thigh; from the thoracic spine, it tracks along the chest wall; from the cervical spine, into the retropharyngeal space; and infection can travel along the perivertebral ligaments for many segments, giving the 'skip lesions' of multiple vertebrae with normal vertebrae between them.
Watch outA 'cold abscess' is a clinical description of the temperature of the swelling, not a dismissal of its seriousness. It is an abscess full of caseous material and viable mycobacteria; it will track, it will burst through the skin as a chronic sinus, and its presence in the groin or the flank without a hot, red, painful local reaction is one of the classic discriminating signs in a long-exam question.
Clinical features and stages
| Stage | Symptoms and signs | Radiograph |
|---|---|---|
| Stage I (stage of onset) | Insidious back or neck pain, worse on movement and at night, stiffness, and the constitutional symptoms of tuberculosis — evening fever, night sweats, weight loss and anorexia. The child becomes irritable and stops playing | Normal, or only slight disc-space narrowing and loss of the normal lordotic curve |
| Stage II (stage of destruction) | Pain increases; muscle spasm; a local tenderness and a palpable step in the spinous processes; abscess appears | Reduction of the disc space, anterior osteoporosis, and destruction of the anterior vertebral bodies with a late paravertebral shadow |
| Stage III (stage of collapse) | The kyphotic deformity becomes obvious and fixed; the shoulders round forward in thoracic disease; the gait becomes short-stepped and guarded | Vertebral collapse with anterior wedging, the angular kyphosis, and a paravertebral cold abscess |
| Stage IV (stage of neural involvement) | Paraplegia (Pott's paraplegia), with spasticity, hyperreflexia, a sensory level and bladder and bowel dysfunction | The radiographic destruction that explains it: retropulsion of bone, granulation tissue or a sequestrum in the canal, or the severe kyphotic ridge over the cord |
The management of the stage depends on the stage, which is the practical value of the classification. Stage I needs chemotherapy and nothing else. Stage II may need drainage of an abscess and, sometimes, surgery to correct a progressive deformity. Stage III usually needs surgical anterior decompression and stabilisation to stop the kyphosis. Stage IV is a surgical emergency.
NoteThe early/late distinction is the examinable point, and it is a real difference for the patient. Early paraplegia is compression by active, soft, reversible inflammatory material, and prompt surgical decompression plus chemotherapy usually recovers it. Late paraplegia is a stretched, atrophic cord over a bony ridge, and the paralysis is partly irreversible no matter how well the decompression is done. So a paraplegia in a patient with a recent diagnosis and active disease is urgent; a paraplegia decades later in a healed kyphosis is a different and harder problem.
Diagnosis and management
| Test | What it gives |
|---|---|
| Blood tests | ESR is raised in about 80% and is useful for monitoring; CRP is usually normal or only slightly raised (in contrast to a pyogenic infection); anaemia and lymphocytosis are common |
| Imaging — plain radiographs | Disc-space narrowing, paradiscal vertebral destruction, paravertebral abscess shadows, and the kyphotic deformity. The earliest and cheapest test and the one that documents the deformity for comparison |
| Imaging — MRI | The investigation of choice: shows the extent of vertebral destruction, the disc involvement, the paravertebral and epidural abscess, and the degree of cord compression. Essential before any surgery |
| Imaging — CT | Defines the bony destruction and the canal in the later, more sclerotic stages better than any other modality |
| Microbiology | Aspiration or biopsy of an abscess, or of vertebral tissue; acid-fast smear and culture; nucleic acid amplification testing for rapid species and resistance identification. This is how the diagnosis is confirmed |
| Histology | Caseating granulomas with Langhans giant cells from the biopsy |
| Treatment | Principle |
|---|---|
| Anti-tuberculous chemotherapy | The mainstay: a multi-drug regimen (isoniazid, rifampicin, pyrazinamide and ethambutol for the intensive phase, then two drugs for the continuation phase) given for 9-12 months under direct observation. Never treat a suspected case without a specimen where a specimen can be obtained |
| Rest and support | A spinal brace or, historically, bed rest, in the earlier stages while the spine is at risk of collapse |
| Surgical drainage | Drainage of a large cold abscess, particularly when it threatens to burst or is causing symptoms |
| Surgical decompression | For neurological deficit, especially early-onset paraplegia: anterior decompression of the canal to remove the sequestrum, granulation tissue or pus |
| Surgical stabilisation / correction | For progressive or severe kyphosis: fusion and instrumentation, or corrective osteotomy in a fixed severe deformity. Indicated when the deformity is over about 60° or progressive |
Watch outThe most important treatment rule: never start anti-tuberculous chemotherapy for a presumed spinal tuberculosis without attempting to obtain material for culture. The organism must be identified and its drug sensitivities known, because a partially treated infection with an unknown organism and unknown resistance is a disease that cannot be managed — and because abscess aspiration and biopsy are the same procedure that decompresses the patient.
A patient with back pain for eight months, weight loss and night sweats has a radiograph showing destruction of two adjacent vertebral bodies with early disc-space destruction and a large paravertebral shadow. What clinical feature would confirm your suspicion that this is tuberculosis rather than a pyogenic infection, and why?
Poliomyelitis
The pathology explains every feature of the disease and every one of its deformities. The virus destroys the anterior horn cell — the final common path for the lower motor neuron — so the muscle it supplies becomes weak and then flaccid, its tendon reflex disappears, and it wastes with fasciculations. Sensation is untouched, because the posterior horn and the dorsal columns are spared. The paralysis is asymmetric because the virus attacks scattered groups of anterior horn cells rather than a whole segment at once. And because growth depends on muscle pull, the limb that is paralysed in childhood grows shorter than its fellow — which is the origin of the limb-length discrepancy that dominates the orthopaedic rehabilitation.
| Feature | Why it happens |
|---|---|
| Asymmetric flaccid paralysis | Scattered groups of anterior horn cells are destroyed, not a whole cord segment; and the lower motor neuron lesion produces flaccid, not spastic, weakness |
| Preserved sensation | The sensory pathways in the dorsal columns and the spinothalamic tract are spared |
| Absent tendon reflexes and fasciculations | The final common path is destroyed, so the reflex arc is broken and the surviving motor units are denervated |
| Muscle imbalance | Paralysis is uneven between agonist and antagonist, so the unopposed muscle wins, and the limb slowly takes up a fixed deformity — most commonly equinus at the ankle from an unopposed tibialis anterior, flexion-adduction at the hip, and recurvatum at the knee |
| Shortening of the limb | Muscle pull is required for normal growth of the bone: a paralysed limb is also a shorter limb, with the discrepancy growing as the child grows |
Watch outTwo decades of eradication effort are undone by one missed vaccination schedule. In a region with under-immunised children, a febrile prodrome followed by an asymmetric flaccid weakness with areflexia and preserved sensation is poliomyelitis until proven otherwise, and the differential includes Guillain-Barré syndrome (symmetric, with sensory loss and a raised CSF protein without cells), transverse myelitis, and other enteroviruses. Public health notification is mandatory.
NotePrevention is the treatment, and it is one of the great public-health successes: oral polio vaccine (Sabin, live attenuated) and inactivated polio vaccine (Salk) have reduced wild poliomyelitis by more than 99% since 1988. The orthopaedic legacy in endemic regions is still a live problem, however, because the patients who were paralysed as children now present as adults with deformity, shortening and degenerative change.
Orthopaedic management of the residual paralysis
| Problem | Orthopaedic approach |
|---|---|
| Fixed muscle imbalance | Tenotomy or tendon transfer to rebalance the joint: transfer an unopposed, still-working muscle to the paralysed side, so that the joint is held in a functional position |
| Equinus deformity of the foot | A below-knee caliper (ankle-foot orthosis) to hold the ankle at 90°; a tendon lengthening or a triple arthrodesis for a fixed deformity in the older child or adult |
| Genu recurvatum or flexion contracture | An orthosis, or an osteotomy and fusion; the aim is a plantigrade foot, a straight knee and a hip that extends, so the patient can stand and walk |
| Limb-length discrepancy | Measured by scanography, and treated by an epiphyseodesis (arrest of the growing side) if the predicted discrepancy is moderate, or by limb lengthening if it is large |
| Flail limb | An orthosis that holds the joint stable without attempting muscle rebalancing; the patient uses the flail limb as a strut only |
| Wheelchair and seating provision | For the patient with a bilateral or extensive involvement, a properly fitted chair and a pressure-relief regimen to prevent pressure ulcers — the single most valuable intervention |
The principle of tendon transfer deserves a sentence, because it is the most distinctive operation in this field. A transfer takes a muscle whose strength is Grade 4 (or better), whose antagonist is irreversibly paralysed, and which can be routed to replace a paralysed muscle of similar function. The transferred muscle loses one grade of power, so it is never done to a muscle that is weaker than Grade 4, and it is never done to a muscle that is already working adequately — the aim is to correct an imbalance, not to add muscle.
Why does a limb recovered from poliomyelitis end up shorter than its fellow, and when in the child's life does that discrepancy get worse?
Common mistakes
Watch outExpecting a fever and a raised CRP in spinal tuberculosis. The disease is cold and indolent: the CRP is usually normal or only slightly raised, the ESR is raised in about 80% and is useful only for monitoring the response, and the patient may have had months of night pain with night sweats when they first present. Waiting for the laboratory picture of a pyogenic infection is waiting for something that will not come.
Watch outMissing posterior (neural arch) tuberculosis. The paradiscal pattern is the classic, but when the posterior elements are the site of disease, the cord can be compressed with little vertebral-body destruction and a relatively normal-looking plain film. A patient with a focal spinal tenderness, a neurological deficit, no systemic sign and an unimpressive radiograph still needs an MRI.
Watch outTreating a poliomyelitis-like picture as a stroke or a cord lesion. Poliomyelitis is an asymmetric, flaccid, lower-motor-neuron paralysis with preserved sensation and normal CSF in most cases. The combination of asymmetry, flaccidity, areflexia and intact sensation is the diagnosis at the bedside.
Watch outOperating on a fixed deformity in a young child before the paralysis is stable. Muscle balance changes over the two years after the acute illness, so a transfer or a tenotomy done too early may be wrong when the paralysis has matured. Assess repeatedly, operate only when the weakness has been static, and protect growth in the meantime with an orthosis.
Check your understanding
Give the four clinical stages of Pott's disease with the radiographic finding at each.
How does tuberculous infection reach the psoas sheath and why does a psoas abscess appear in the groin?
What are the five orthopaedic consequences of a childhood poliomyelitis?
Multiple choice
A 45-year-old with back pain, night sweats and weight loss has MRI showing contiguous involvement of three vertebral bodies with relative sparing of the discs and a large paravertebral cold abscess. Which statement best characterises this disease?
A 2-year-old in an under-immunised area has a febrile prodrome and then asymmetric flaccid weakness of the legs with absent tendon reflexes, fasciculations and preserved sensation. Which mechanism underlies the paralysis?
Which statement about anti-tuberculous chemotherapy in Pott's disease is correct?