Learning outcomes
By the end of this lesson you should be able to: describe the common fractures of the clavicle, proximal humerus, humeral shaft, elbow, forearm, distal radius and hand, with the mechanism of each; state the nerve injured in a fracture of the surgical neck and of the mid-shaft of the humerus, and explain the different deficits; describe the three named fractures of this lesson — Colles', supracondylar and scaphoid — and the specific complication of each; explain why a scaphoid fracture must be suspected, immobilised and re-imaged despite a normal initial film; recognise the acute complications of a supracondylar fracture of the humerus in a child; and describe the examination and management of a wrist injury in the emergency department.
Prerequisites
Lesson 1 (Fractures & dislocations) and Lesson 2 (healing and complications). From Gross Anatomy I: the brachial plexus and its five terminal branches, the course of the radial, ulnar and median nerves, and the bones and joints of the upper limb.
The big idea
One mechanism explains most of this lesson. Land on an outstretched hand and the force has to go somewhere: it breaks the distal radius in an adult (Colles'), the supracondylar region in a child, the scaphoid in a young adult, or the clavicle if the force is transmitted through the shoulder instead. The reason the same mechanism produces different fractures at different ages is that each age has a different weakest link — the weak metaphysis of a child, the dense bone of an athlete, or the osteoporotic cortex of an older adult.
NoteThe upper limb is built for placement of the hand, not for load bearing. That is why an upper-limb malunion is tolerated far better than a lower-limb one: the shoulder and trunk can compensate for angulation in the humerus in a way the knee and ankle cannot for angulation in the tibia. The exception is the forearm, where rotation has no compensating mechanism — see the theory question below.
Shoulder girdle and humerus
| Injury | Mechanism | Characteristic | Nerve at risk |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fracture of the clavicle (middle third) | Fall onto the shoulder or an outstretched hand; a direct blow in sport | The commonest fracture in children; the distal fragment drops under the weight of the arm; the patient supports the elbow | Rarely a nerve; brachial plexus and subclavian vessels if displaced |
| Acromioclavicular dislocation | Direct blow to the point of the shoulder — a fall onto the acromion | A step at the AC joint; the 'piano key' sign on downward pressure | None |
| Fracture of the proximal humerus | Fall onto the outstretched hand in an older patient | Bruising tracks down the arm; Neer classification by parts and displacement | Axillary nerve (as in shoulder dislocation) |
| Fracture of the surgical neck | Fall onto the shoulder | Treated by the nerve, not the fracture, in most cases | Axillary nerve — badge-patch numbness and deltoid paralysis |
| Fracture of the humeral shaft | Fall onto the arm; a direct blow; a twisting injury in a child | Radial nerve palsy is the classic association; most unite in a functional brace | Radial nerve in the spiral (radial) groove — wrist drop and loss over the first dorsal web space |
| Supracondylar fracture (extension type) | Fall onto an outstretched hand with the elbow extended, in a child aged 5-8 | The swollen, deformed elbow; the commonest fracture of the child's elbow | Brachial artery and the median nerve — see below |
Watch outThe distinction to memorise: a fracture of the surgical neck of the humerus risks the axillary nerve (deltoid, badge patch), a fracture of the mid-shaft risks the radial nerve in the spiral groove (wrist drop, first dorsal web space), and a supracondylar fracture risks the brachial artery and median nerve. The same bone, three different levels, three different injuries — and each one must be tested for and documented.
Most closed humeral shaft fractures are treated without surgery, in a functional brace. This is one of the few places in orthopaedics where a large radiographic deformity is genuinely acceptable, because the shoulder compensates. The reason to operate is the nerve that has been lacerated rather than bruised (an acute, complete radial palsy with an open fracture or a spiral Holstein-Lewis pattern), a vascular injury, or a fracture that has failed in a brace.
The elbow and forearm
The supracondylar fracture is the reason paediatric elbow injuries are taken seriously. Two things can go wrong, and both go wrong fast. The brachial artery is stretched across the displaced proximal fragment or kinked by it, so the limb loses its perfusion; and the median nerve, which lies in front of the elbow, is compressed. Both must be assessed at the first examination and after every manipulation.
| Complication | How it shows | What you do |
|---|---|---|
| Brachial artery injury | Absent radial pulse, pallor, cold hand, pain, a slowly filling capillary refill | Urgent reduction; the pulse usually returns with the reduction. If it does not, surgical exploration of the artery |
| Median nerve injury | Loss of flexion of the index finger (flexor digitorum profundus and superficialis), loss of opposition of the thumb, numbness in the radial 3½ digits | Document before and after reduction; most are neurapraxias that recover |
| Volkmann's ischaemic contracture | The late sequel — a clawed, insensate hand with fixed flexion of the wrist and fingers | Prevention by recognizing and treating compartment syndrome early; established contracture cannot be reversed |
| Malunion / cubitus varus | The classic 'gunstock' deformity when reduction is lost | Accurate reduction and percutaneous pinning rather than a cast alone for displaced fractures |
Watch outThe three signs of a vascular injury in a child's supracondylar fracture are absent pulse, pain and pallor — and the two that matter most are pain and pallor. An absent pulse that does not return after reduction is a surgical emergency. A pulse that returns and then disappears again is the pattern of an expanding haematoma or a traumatised, spasming artery, and it demands exploration, not another wait-and-see.
A seven-year-old falls on an outstretched hand and has a swollen, deformed elbow with no radial pulse and a pale hand. After reduction under anaesthesia the hand remains pale and pulseless. What do you do next and why?
Wrist and hand: the three named injuries
Three fractures of the wrist and forearm are so heavily examined that each has its own entry. Learn the mechanism, the deformity, the complication and the pitfall of each.
| Colles' fracture | Scaphoid fracture | |
|---|---|---|
| Mechanism | Fall onto an outstretched hand in an older woman with osteoporotic bone | Fall onto an outstretched hand in a young adult, or a forced dorsiflexion of the wrist |
| Where | Distal radius, within 2.5 cm of the articular surface | Waist of the scaphoid in most cases |
| Deformity | Dorsal displacement and angulation — the 'dinner fork' deformity; radial shortening gives ulnar styloid prominence | No deformity; the only sign is tenderness in the anatomical snuffbox |
| Complication | Malunion with dorsal tilt; carpal malalignment; median nerve symptoms; stiffness of the fingers; rupture of extensor pollicis longus | Avascular necrosis of the proximal pole; non-union; radiographically occult early on |
| Treatment | Manipulation and plaster, or a volar locking plate in a younger patient; early finger movement | Thumb-spica cast or surgical fixation; the cast is applied on clinical suspicion, not on the film |
| The exam answer | 'Dinner fork' is the description; the failure to move the fingers from day one is the commonest cause of a poor result | Snuffbox tenderness equals scaphoid fracture until proven otherwise |
A 68-year-old woman trips on a kerb, lands on her right hand, and has a dinner-fork deformity with a dorsally displaced distal radius on the film. She is manipulated under haematoma block or a Bier's block and put in a cast from below the elbow to the metacarpal heads. The most important instruction she is given is not about the cast but about her fingers: she must move them from the first day, because a stiff hand after a healed Colles' fracture is the commonest cause of an unhappy patient.
The scaphoid deserves its own emphasis because it is the most commonly missed injury in the emergency department, and the missed injury is the one that costs the patient most.
Watch outA scaphoid fracture is invisible on the first radiograph in roughly 20-25% of cases. The rule is therefore not a radiological rule but a clinical one: if there is tenderness in the anatomical snuffbox, treat as a scaphoid fracture. Immobilise the wrist in a scaphoid (thumb-spica) cast and repeat the radiographs — or obtain an MRI/CT if you need certainty now — in 10-14 days. Reviewing the original films is not the same as re-imaging the patient.
| Why the scaphoid is different | Consequence |
|---|---|
| It has a retrograde blood supply — vessels enter the distal half and run backwards | A fracture of the waist or proximal pole cuts off the proximal fragment: avascular necrosis and non-union |
| Its articular cartilage covers most of its surface, leaving a small area for vessels to enter | There is little capacity to heal, so the fracture is slow and easily missed |
| It is the most commonly fractured carpal bone | It is the fracture you think of first in every young adult with a wrist injury |
| A missed fracture may declare itself months later with wrist pain and arthritis | A late diagnosis is treated surgically; the late diagnosis is the avoidable harm |
The rest of the hand follows the same logic of mechanism: a fall on an outstretched hand with axial load drives the capitate or lunate, giving a perilunate dislocation; a direct blow to the tip of the finger gives a mallet finger (extensor tendon avulsion) or a flexor digitorum profundus rupture (a jersey finger); and a punch thrown at a wall gives a fracture of the neck of the fifth metacarpal, the boxer's fracture. And remember that a hand swollen from a wrist injury is stiff unless the fingers are moved.
Examining the upper limb
The upper-limb nerve examination is not a list to recite; it is a set of movements and patches of skin you test in a fixed order so that you do not forget one. The order that saves time is from proximal to distal, matching the arrangement you learned in anatomy.
| Nerve | Motor test | Sensory patch |
|---|---|---|
| Axillary (C5-C6) | Abduct the shoulder against resistance (deltoid) | Regimental badge patch on the lateral shoulder |
| Radial (C5-C8) | Extend the wrist and fingers (wrist drop if lost) | First dorsal web space |
| Median (C6-T1) | Flex the index finger; oppose the thumb (loin — 'LOAF': lateral lumbricals, opponents, abductor pollicis brevis, flexor pollicis brevis) | Radial side of the index finger, or the palmar thenar eminence |
| Ulnar (C8-T1) | Abduct the little finger (first dorsal interosseous) / cross the fingers | Little finger |
| Musculocutaneous (C5-C6) | Flex the elbow against resistance (biceps) | Lateral forearm |
NoteA single, quick way to test three nerves at once: ask the patient to make a fist, extend the wrist, and spread the fingers. The fist tests the long flexors (median and ulnar), wrist extension tests the radial nerve, and finger spread tests the ulnar nerve. Two seconds, three nerves, and it is the same set you will repeat at every review.
Common mistakes
Watch outDischarging a young adult with wrist pain after FOOSH because the radiograph is normal. In a snapshot of 20-25% the fracture is occult. Tenderness in the snuffbox is a positive clinical finding and mandates immobilisation and repeat imaging, not reassurance. This is the single most common medicolegally significant miss in upper-limb practice.
Watch outTesting the nerve and then reducing the fracture without testing it again. Document sensation and movement before and after every manipulation, because you must be able to say whether the nerve injury happened on the football pitch or on your examination couch. An undocumented pre-reduction examination cannot protect you.
Watch outConfusing the nerve injured at the surgical neck of the humerus with the nerve injured at the mid-shaft. Surgical neck: axillary nerve, deltoid and the badge patch. Mid-shaft: radial nerve, wrist drop and the first dorsal web space. The level of the fracture on the film tells you the nerve before you touch the patient.
Watch outPutting an upper-limb fracture in a cast and forgetting the fingers. A stiff hand or a frozen shoulder after a healed forearm or humeral fracture is a complication of the treatment, not of the injury, and it is the one that determines whether the patient returns to work. Move the uninjured joints from day one and write that instruction in the notes and in the discharge letter.
Check your understanding
A 24-year-old falls onto his outstretched hand and has tenderness in the anatomical snuffbox with a normal radiograph. What is the correct management, and what is the risk if it is ignored?
How do you distinguish a fracture of the surgical neck from one of the mid-shaft of the humerus by nerve examination alone, and why does the level of the fracture predict the nerve?
Why does a forearm (radius and ulna) fracture require a much more accurate reduction than a humeral shaft fracture, when both are upper-limb long bones?
Multiple choice
A 22-year-old falls onto an outstretched hand and has tenderness in the anatomical snuffbox. The initial wrist radiographs are normal. What is the most appropriate next step?
A seven-year-old falls onto an outstretched hand and has a displaced extension-type supracondylar fracture with a swollen elbow. Which is the most feared acute complication?
A patient with a mid-shaft fracture of the humerus cannot extend the wrist and has numbness over the first dorsal web space. Which nerve is injured, and where does it lie?