Learning outcomes
By the end of this lesson you should be able to: distinguish intracapsular (femoral neck) from extracapsular (intertrochanteric) fracture of the proximal femur and state the operation used for each; recognise posterior hip dislocation and its emergency management; describe the assessment of the acutely injured knee — the Lachman test, the pivot-shift, the posterior drawer and the meniscal signs; explain the 'unhappy triad' and the significance of a haemarthrosis; describe the Ottawa ankle rules and when to radiograph a twisted ankle; recognise slipped upper femoral epiphysis in an adolescent and say why the knee must be examined in every child with a limp; and explain why a tibial shaft fracture carries the highest risk of compartment syndrome of any injury in this course.
Prerequisites
Lessons 1-2 (fractures, healing and compartment syndrome). From Gross Anatomy I: the ligaments and menisci of the knee, the cruciate and collateral ligaments, the femoral blood supply, the common fibular nerve at the fibular neck, and the tendons and nerves around the ankle.
The big idea
The lower limb is built to bear weight, and that changes everything about its injuries. There is no compensation for angulation here — the ankle is a hinge, the knee is a hinge, and a limb that heals even 5° out of true transmits force abnormally for the rest of the patient's life. So the standards for reduction are higher, the operations are more invasive, and the consequences of a missed injury are measured in decades of osteoarthritis rather than in a season of discomfort.
NoteThe single most useful fact about the hip: the femoral head's blood supply runs backwards. The retinacular branches of the medial and lateral circumflex femoral arteries climb the femoral neck beneath the synovial reflection, so a fracture inside the capsule that tears them leaves the head avascular, and a fracture outside the capsule leaves them intact. That one sentence explains both operations and both prognoses.
Fractures of the hip
| Intracapsular (neck of femur) | Extracapsular (intertrochanteric) | |
|---|---|---|
| Relationship to capsule | Inside the hip joint capsule | Outside the capsule |
| Blood supply to the head | Retinacular vessels torn; head becomes avascular | Retinacular vessels intact; head retains its supply |
| Typical patient | Older woman with osteoporosis; a fall from standing height | Older patient, often with a higher-energy fall |
| Limb position | Shortened, externally rotated (usually less markedly than extracapsular) | Shortened, externally rotated, often dramatically so |
| Operation | Hemiarthroplasty or total hip replacement — the head is replaced because it cannot heal | Dynamic hip screw or intramedullary nail — fracture is reduced and fixed, and the head is kept |
| Why the difference | Fixation of an avascular head leads to non-union and avascular necrosis | The bone is well vascularised, so it heals when stably fixed |
The externally rotated and shortened limb in a fall from standing height in an elderly patient is a fracture of the proximal femur until proven otherwise. This is one of the fractures where the radiograph can be misleadingly normal in an undisplaced intracapsular fracture, so if the clinical picture is there and the film is not, obtain an MRI or repeat imaging rather than discharging the patient. A missed undisplayed intracapsular fracture displaces on the way home and becomes a problem that cannot be fixed.
Watch outA young patient with a femoral neck fracture is a different problem entirely: the bone is normal, so the energy was high, and the fracture is usually grossly displaced. Anatomical reduction and internal fixation with the head still viable is the priority — a replacement in a 30-year-old is a life sentence of revision operations. Age alters the operation, and the mechanism alters the urgency.
An 82-year-old woman cannot get up after a fall at home. Her leg is shortened and externally rotated and she cannot bear weight. Why is the radiograph not the last word, and what would you do if the first film is normal?
Femoral shaft and below
| Injury | Mechanism and site | Key points |
|---|---|---|
| Femoral shaft fracture | High-energy trauma in the young; a trivial fall in the osteoporotic elderly | Blood loss of 1.5-2 L into the thigh — this is a haemorrhagic injury, not just a fracture. Treat with an intramedullary nail; traction is the temporary splint |
| Fracture of the patella | Direct blow to the knee (dashboard) or a resisted extension | The knee cannot extend against gravity; an avulsion of the extensor mechanism must be fixed surgically |
| Tibial shaft fracture | Direct blow, often in a road traffic collision or sport; the commonest open fracture of a long bone | The anterior compartment lies against the subcutaneous tibia: watch for compartment syndrome. Commonest site of non-union of a long bone |
| Ankle fracture (bimalleolar / trimalleolar) | An inversion or eversion injury with rotational force | Assess stability: the mortise must be congruent. Talar shift is the sign of an unstable mortise that needs fixation |
| Fracture of the calcaneus | Fall from a height onto the heels | Look for the associated lumbar burst fracture — falls are axial, and they break both ends |
| Tarsometatarsal (Lisfranc) injury | Axial load through a plantarflexed foot, or a crushing injury | The foot is swollen and the patient cannot bear weight; frequently missed on plain films and a frequent source of litigation |
Watch outEvery fall from a height is examined at both ends. A patient who lands on their heels has taken an axial load through the spine, and roughly 10% have a lumbar (or thoracolumbar) spine fracture that the painful heels completely mask. A patient who jumped with the intention of self-harm should also be assessed for the cervical spine before the heels are interpreted.
Tibial shaft fractures are the fracture to know in this lesson. The subcutaneous border of the tibia means a direct blow readily opens the fracture, so it is the commonest site of open fracture of a long bone. The tibia's blood supply is segmental, so a mid-shaft fracture can deprive a fragment. And the anterior compartment lies directly against the bone and is the tightest compartment in the leg, so it is here that compartment syndrome is most often seen.
The acutely injured knee
A knee swells within about two hours of a ligament rupture, and the swelling is a haemarthrosis — blood in the joint from a torn structure inside it. That observation alone narrows the differential enormously: in a haemarthrosis after a twisting injury, you are looking for a torn anterior cruciate ligament, an osteochondral fracture, or a peripheral meniscal tear. The examination is then four tests, done in an order, and compared with the other knee.
| Test | What it tests | What a positive test means |
|---|---|---|
| Lachman test (knee at 30°, femur stabilised, tibia drawn forward) | The anterior cruciate ligament — the most sensitive and specific test | Increased forward translation of the tibia with a soft or absent endpoint: ACL rupture. This is the test to trust |
| Anterior drawer (knee at 90°) | The anterior cruciate ligament | Forward translation with a soft endpoint; less reliable than Lachman, especially in the acutely painful or swollen knee |
| Pivot shift | The anterior cruciate ligament, functionally | The tibia reduces with a clunk as the knee is extended; a positive test is the rotatory instability that patients feel as 'the knee gives way' |
| Posterior drawer | The posterior cruciate ligament | Backward translation of the tibia; a posterior sag is best seen with the hips and knees at 90° looking from the side |
| Valgus / varus stress at 0° and 30° | The medial and lateral collateral ligaments | At 30° the ligament is isolated; at 0° opening suggests a capsular or cruciate injury in addition |
| Joint-line tenderness and McMurray's test | The medial or lateral meniscus | Tenderness at the joint line; a click or pain at the extremes of flexion-extension with rotation. Less specific than MRI |
NoteThe unhappy triad is the anterior cruciate ligament, the medial collateral ligament and the medial meniscus, injured by a valgus force with a twisting component — a foot planted and a blow to the lateral side of the knee. The medial meniscus is involved because its deep fibres are bound to the medial collateral ligament, so a valgus force that tears the ligament tears the meniscus too. The lateral meniscus escapes because it is loosely attached and mobile.
A 22-year-old footballer twists a planted knee, hears a pop, and is off the pitch within minutes. The knee swells over the next two hours. Lachman is positive with a soft endpoint, and the pivot shift is positive. The diagnosis is a rupture of the anterior cruciate ligament; the haemarthrosis confirms that something inside the joint has torn. The management question is not the diagnosis but the patient's demands — a young athlete who wants to return to pivoting sport will need reconstruction, while a patient who is content with a straight-line life may be managed with rehabilitation and a brace.
The adolescent with a painful knee: SCFE
| Feature | What it looks like |
|---|---|
| Patient | An obese or rapidly growing adolescent, 10-16 years, boys more than girls; the commonest hip disorder of adolescence |
| Pain | Groin, thigh or knee pain — referred to the knee by the obturator nerve, which is why it is missed so often |
| Gait | A limp with the leg externally rotated; the patient cannot stand on the affected leg |
| Signs | Fixed external rotation that is obligatory on hip flexion; loss of internal rotation are the earliest findings |
| Radiographs | AP and frog-leg (lateral) views of both hips: the epiphysis slips posteriorly and medially, so the AP view can be normal and the frog-leg view essential |
| Complications | Avascular necrosis of the femoral head (the most feared); chondrolysis; contralateral slip in up to 20-40% |
| Treatment | Non-weight-bearing on diagnosis, then surgical fixation in situ (usually with a single screw). Do NOT attempt closed reduction |
Watch outEvery child or adolescent with knee pain must have the hip examined. The obturator nerve refers pain from the hip to the medial thigh and knee, so a slipped capital femoral epiphysis, a Perthes' disease or a septic arthritis of the hip all can present as nothing more than a painful knee in a child who walks with a limp. Examining only the knee is the classic error, and the missed slip goes on to avascular necrosis.
Watch outA suspected slip is made non-weight-bearing immediately and fixed surgically. Forcing the hip — as in a closed reduction to 'improve' the position of the head — risks tearing the retinacular vessels and precipitating avascular necrosis. The aim is to prevent further slip and to stabilise, not to restore the epiphysis to its original position.
The twisted ankle
| Rule | Radiograph the ankle if... | Radiograph the foot if... |
|---|---|---|
| Bony tenderness | Posterior edge or tip of either malleolus (the lateral and medial malleoli), distal 6 cm of bone | Tenderness at the navicular or the base of the fifth metatarsal |
| Inability to bear weight | The patient cannot take four steps both immediately after the injury and at the time of examination | The same test applies to the foot series |
| Point of the rule | Sensitivity approaching 100% for clinically significant fractures | Identifies the avulsion fracture of the base of the fifth metatarsal and the Lisfranc patterns |
NoteThe Ottawa rules are a safety net, not a substitute for judgement: they do not tell you there is no fracture, they tell you the chance of a clinically important fracture is low enough that imaging is not needed in the first visit. Apply them to an injury within the last ten days, in a patient who is not intoxicated and has no other painful injury, and who is able to cooperate. And they do not apply to the obviously deformed ankle — that is radiographed and reduced, not decided upon by a rule.
Common mistakes
Watch outOperating on every proximal femur fracture the same way. The capsule decides the operation: an intracapsular fracture gets a replacement because the head is avascular; an extracapsular fracture gets a hip screw or nail because the head is viable and bone heals when fixed. Applying the wrong operation to the wrong fracture is the single commonest error made by juniors reading an X-ray on the trauma meeting.
Watch outTrusting an AP radiograph to exclude a slipped capital femoral epiphysis. The slip is posterior and medial, so it can be invisible on the AP view and obvious on the frog-leg lateral. Request both hips in both projections, and remember the contralateral hip will be involved in up to 20-40% of cases.
Watch outStopping the knee examination at the cruciates. The collateral ligaments, the menisci and the extensor mechanism all need testing, and the patellar tendon and quadriceps must be checked for continuity — a patient with an extensor mechanism rupture cannot extend the knee against gravity, and that is the one injury the drawer tests will not find.
Watch outMissing a compartment syndrome in a tibial fracture. The anterior compartment is the tightest and lies directly against the subcutaneous tibia, so a tibial shaft fracture is the classic setting for the syndrome. Serial examination, and a low threshold for fasciotomy, are the standard — not a single reassuring pulse palpation on admission.
Check your understanding
Why does an intracapsular fracture of the neck of femur in an 80-year-old get a hemiarthroplasty, while an intertrochanteric fracture in a patient of the same age gets a dynamic hip screw?
A 13-year-old boy with a limp complains of knee pain. The knee examination is normal. What have you missed?
State the two components of the Ottawa ankle rule, and the two sites whose tenderness prompts an ankle radiograph rather than a foot radiograph.
Multiple choice
An obese 13-year-old boy has a limp with groin and referred knee pain and an externally rotated gait; frog-leg radiographs confirm a stable slipped upper femoral epiphysis. What is the correct management?
A footballer twists a planted knee, hears a pop and develops rapid swelling. Lachman shows increased anterior tibial translation with a soft endpoint, the pivot shift is positive and the posterior drawer is normal. Which structure is torn?
An 80-year-old woman falls and has a shortened, externally rotated leg. Which statement about the fracture of her proximal femur is correct?