Learning outcomes
By the end of this lesson you should be able to: describe the stages of fracture healing and the difference between primary (direct) and secondary (callus) healing; define delayed union, non-union and malunion, give a time threshold for each, and list the causes you can actually influence; list the local and systemic complications of fracture; recognise acute compartment syndrome clinically, name the six Ps, and say why fasciotomy is the only definitive treatment; explain the mechanism and timing of fat embolism syndrome; and describe avascular necrosis, Volkmann's ischaemic contracture and myositis ossificans.
Prerequisites
Lesson 1 (Fractures & dislocations): the descriptors, the open-fracture rules and the five complications that must not be missed. You should also recall from Gross Anatomy I the blood supply of the femoral head and the compartments of the leg.
The big idea
Bone is the one tissue in the body that heals by forming scar tissue and then replacing it with exactly the tissue that was there — no fibrosis, no loss of architecture. That is remarkable, and it happens because bone has a two-part system: the hard tissue does the mechanical work, and the living cells on every internal and external surface keep measuring load and rebuilding the tissue accordingly. When you break a bone, you unleash the mesenchymal stem cells of the periosteum and endosteum, and they lay down woven bone as quickly and as strongly as the local strain allows.
NoteThe three requirements for healing, again: mechanical stability, adequate blood supply, and contact between viable bone surfaces. Everything in this lesson is a failure of one of those three, or a complication of the force that caused the fracture. Diagnose which of the three failed and you have diagnosed why the bone did not join.
The stages of healing
Healing is continuous, but it is worth naming the stages because each has a clinical signature on the radiograph and in the room.
| Stage | Timing | What is happening | What you see |
|---|---|---|---|
| Impact | Immediate | Cells at the fracture site die; the haematoma forms and organises | A radiolucent line that looks wider than it was on day one |
| Inflammation | First 48 hours to ~2 weeks | Haematoma organisation, vascular ingrowth, inflammatory cells clear debris | Soft-tissue swelling; bony change is not yet visible |
| Repair (soft then hard callus) | ~2 weeks to ~3 months | Periosteal and endosteal cells lay down cartilage and then woven bone, bridging the gap | Fuzzy periosteal new bone and a visible callus cuff on serial films |
| Remodelling | Months to years | Woven bone is replaced by lamellar bone along the lines of stress; the medulla is re-established | The fracture line becomes indistinct and the bone resumes its normal contour |
Two points on timing that are examinable. A fracture is 'sticky' at around six to eight weeks, when clinical union is declared — no pain on loading, no movement at the site, no tenderness. Radiographic union lags behind clinical union by weeks, and remodelling continues for a year or more. That gap is why a child with a broken wrist is told to remove the cast at six weeks even though the film still shows the line clearly.
Watch outChildren heal faster (roughly half the adult time), the elderly heal more slowly, and healing at the metaphysis — with its rich blood supply and cancellous bone — is far faster than healing at the mid-diaphysis, where the cortical bone is dense and the blood supply is segmental. That is why a mid-shaft scaphoid or tibial fracture is a therapeutic headache while a Colles' fracture is not.
Primary versus secondary healing
| Primary (direct) healing | Secondary (callus) healing | |
|---|---|---|
| How it is achieved | Rigid internal fixation with absolute stability and anatomical contact | Plaster, splint, cast, or a less rigid construct that permits controlled micro-motion |
| What forms | No callus; the gap is crossed by cutting cones and new Haversian bone | A cuff of woven callus around and across the fracture |
| Speed of radiographic union | Slower to show on a film — there is no callus to see | Faster to show, because the callus is visible |
| Where you want it | Intra-articular fractures, where a step in the joint surface must be abolished | Diaphyseal fractures of long bones in a cast |
| What failure looks like | A persistent radiolucent line, or a broken plate with no callus (instability) | A hypertrophic, 'elephant's foot' non-union (instability with movement) |
NoteThe counter-intuitive exam answer: a fracture fixed with a plate and screws that is 'perfectly' rigid may show no callus at all at six weeks and yet be healed, while a fracture in a cast shows a large callus and is still not load-bearing. Callus is not the only proof of union — its absence under rigid fixation is expected.
Delayed union, non-union and malunion
| Diagnosis | Definition | Commonest causes | Treatment principle |
|---|---|---|---|
| Delayed union | No union by the expected time, but the site is still biologically active | Inadequate immobilisation, distraction of the fragments, poor blood supply, smoking, infection | Continue immobilisation and remove the cause — most will unite |
| Non-union (hypertrophic) | Healing has stopped; the ends are sclerotic and flared, with no bridging bone | Excessive motion or distraction — a biology that is fine but mechanics that are not | Provide stability (exchange nailing or plate) — often no bone graft is needed |
| Non-union (atrophic) | Healing has stopped; the ends are rounded, osteoporotic and dry | Loss of blood supply, a gap, infection, poor soft-tissue cover | Biological stimulation — open reduction, bone graft, and stable fixation |
| Malunion | Healed in a functionally unacceptable position | Reduction never achieved, reduction lost, or the fracture was never immobilised properly | Osteotomy to correct the deformity if the functional loss justifies it; cosmetic correction in children rarely indicated |
A 34-year-old has a tibial shaft fracture nailed eleven months ago. The knee is comfortable, there is no pain on walking, but the fracture line is still clearly visible with sclerotic, slightly flared ends and no callus. This is a hypertrophic non-union: the biology is intact (which is why there is callus attempting to form) but the mechanics are wrong — the nail is not providing enough stability. The treatment is exchange nailing to a larger-diameter nail. Add bone graft and you have operated for no biological reason; add electrical stimulation alone and the construct will still move.
Why does a fracture with a large gap (for example after a segmental fracture, or after a badly displaced comminuted fracture) fail to unite even with perfect fixation?
Local complications
Local complications are the ones that affect the limb: they are the reason a broken bone in a skilled pair of hands can still cost a patient the use of their arm.
| Complication | Mechanism | Typical site | The clinical lesson |
|---|---|---|---|
| Avascular necrosis | Interruption of the bone's blood supply; the dead bone collapses and later shows as increased density | Femoral head after intracapsular neck fracture or posterior hip dislocation; scaphoid proximal pole; talus | Displaced intracapsular hip fractures are replaced, not fixed — the head cannot survive |
| Volkmann's ischaemic contracture | Muscle necrosis after untreated compartment syndrome; the dead muscle is replaced by fibrosis that contracts | Flexor compartment of the forearm after a supracondylar fracture; the calf | Fasciotomy done late prevents the contracture but the muscle is already necrotic — so act early |
| Myositis ossificans | Heterotopic bone forming in muscle after trauma or surgery, or after forceful reduction | Elbow (posterior), thigh, hip | Do not forcibly manipulate an elbow repeatedly; reserve surgery until the mass is mature and alkaline phosphatase has fallen |
| Joint stiffness | Immobilising the joint that was not broken; adhesion formation | Knee, elbow, shoulder, hand | Stiffness is prevented by early movement of the uninjured joints, not by cautious waiting |
| Complex regional pain syndrome | Disproportionate, burning pain with swelling, sweating and colour change after injury | Distal limb, often after a Colles' fracture or distal radius surgery | Recognise early; the treatment is analgesia, graded desensitisation and active movement, not rest |
Watch outAvascular necrosis of the femoral head is the classic late sequela of an intracapsular fracture of the neck of femur. The retinacular vessels that supply the head climb the femoral neck from the circumflex femoral arteries, and an intracapsular fracture tears them, while the intra-articular haematoma tamponades them further. Extracapsular fractures lie outside the capsule and leave those vessels intact, which is why the two are treated by entirely different operations.
Compartment syndrome
The mechanism is a closed loop. Bone bleeding or swelling raises the pressure inside a compartment whose walls are bone, interosseous membrane and inelastic fascia. As pressure rises, the thin-walled veins compress first, so venous outflow stops and capillary pressure rises, which adds more oedema, which raises the pressure further. Arterial inflow continues until the pressure approaches the arterial pressure, so the limb keeps its pulse until very late — and the tissue dies while the pulse is still there.
| The six Ps | Significance |
|---|---|
| Pain (out of proportion to the injury) | The earliest and most reliable sign — especially pain on passive stretch of the muscle that runs through the compartment |
| Pallor | A late sign; the limb may look normal for hours |
| Paraesthesia | Nerve ischaemia; the first web space of the foot for the anterior compartment, the sole for the posterior |
| Paralysis | Late; by the time the muscle cannot move, it is already necrotic |
| Pulselessness | The very last sign — waiting for it costs the limb |
| Perishing cold / poikilothermia | A terminal sign; the limb has lost its perfusion |
Watch outTreatment is immediate fasciotomy of every compartment involved, after splitting any cast or dressing that is constricting the limb and removing circumferential dressings. Do not elevate the limb above the heart (it lowers the perfusion pressure), do not apply ice, and do not wait for a pressure measurement when the clinical diagnosis is clear. Pressure monitoring is only for the patient whose examination you cannot trust — the sedated, the head-injured, the child.
Systemic complications
| Complication | Mechanism | Timing | Recognition |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hypovolaemic shock | Blood loss into the tissues; a femur can lose 1.5-2 L, a pelvis 2-3 L or more | Immediate | The blood loss is hidden — look at the fracture, not the wound |
| Fat embolism syndrome | Fat droplets and marrow content enter the venous circulation after long-bone or pelvic trauma, causing a systemic inflammatory and mechanical lung injury | 24-72 hours after injury (not immediately) | The triad: respiratory distress with hypoxaemia, petechiae over the chest and axillae, and cerebral signs; plus tachycardia and fever |
| Deep vein thrombosis and pulmonary embolism | Stasis, immobility and the prothrombotic response to trauma | Days to weeks; after hip fracture from the first day | Prophylaxis is mandatory: low-molecular-weight heparin, early mobilisation, mechanical compression |
| Sepsis | Open fracture contamination, or conversion of closed to open | Any time; the first exposure is at injury | Prophylactic antibiotics, wound excision, tetanus cover |
| Crush syndrome / rhabdomyolysis | Muscle necrosis releasing myoglobin and potassium | After prolonged entrapment or late fasciotomy | Hyperkalaemia, myoglobinuric renal failure — a medical, not a surgical, problem |
| Tetanus / gas gangrene | Contamination with Clostridium tetani or Clostridium perfringens | Days after injury | Tetanus prophylaxis for every open wound; this is not optional |
NoteThe classic exam patient for fat embolism is a young man with a femoral shaft fracture who was well on admission, and 36 hours later becomes confused, tachypnoeic and hypoxic, with petechiae on his chest, axillae and conjunctivae. The petechiae are the discriminating sign, and the treatment is supportive: oxygen, ventilation if needed, and careful fluid resuscitation. Early and stable fixation of the long-bone fracture reduces the incidence.
Common mistakes
Watch outCalling a 4-month-old fracture 'delayed' when it is a non-union. Delayed union is still biologically active — it has not stopped, it is merely slow. Non-union means the healing process has ceased: no radiographic progress on two consecutive films at least 4-6 weeks apart, and no clinical change. The distinction matters because one is treated by waiting and the other by surgery.
Watch outTreating a hypertrophic non-union with bone graft. A hypertrophic non-union has abundant biology attempting to bridge the gap and failing because the construct moves. The treatment is stability — exchange nailing or a better plate. Bone graft is for the atrophic non-union, where the biology has run out. Grafting a mobile non-union is operating for the wrong reason.
Watch outWatching a compartment syndrome until the pulse disappears. The pulse disappears at pressures above arterial systolic, by which time both nerve and muscle are necrotic. The investigation to act on is pain on passive stretch with a tense compartment — the pulse is only useful for confirming a vascular injury, not for excluding a compartment syndrome.
Watch outImmobilising the joints above and below a fracture and then being surprised when they are stiff. The joint that was not broken should be moved from day one — fingers in a forearm plaster, the shoulder in a humeral cast, the ankle and knee in a tibial cast. Stiffness is a complication of treatment, and it is the one you are personally responsible for.
Check your understanding
Give the definitions of delayed union, non-union and malunion, with the time threshold for the first two.
Why does an intracapsular fracture of the femoral neck risk avascular necrosis of the head, while an extracapsular (intertrochanteric) fracture does not?
What is the single most important clinical sign that should prompt you to call for an urgent fasciotomy, and why is a palpable pulse not reassuring?
Multiple choice
Eight hours after nailing of a tibial shaft fracture a patient has pain out of proportion, pain on passive stretch of the toes, paraesthesia and a tense calf. The pulses are present and capillary refill is brisk. What is the correct immediate management?
A tibial fracture fixed with a plate eleven months ago still shows a clear fracture line with sclerotic, slightly flared bone ends and no bridging callus. Which is the most appropriate treatment?
A 22-year-old with a femoral shaft fracture is comfortable on admission, and 36 hours later becomes tachypnoeic, hypoxic and confused, with petechiae over the chest, axillae and conjunctivae. Which complication has occurred?