Learning outcomes
By the end of this lesson you should be able to: define a fracture and use the standard descriptors (site, pattern, displacement, open or closed) to describe one accurately; distinguish closed from open injury and say why the prefix 'compound' no longer belongs in the notes; list the common fracture patterns and the mechanisms that produce them; describe the classic deformity of shoulder and posterior hip dislocation and the nerves at risk in each; state the three aims of fracture management — reduce, hold, rehabilitate — and match each to the options you actually have; and recognise the immediately dangerous injuries that hide behind a broken bone.
Prerequisites
Gross Anatomy I (bones, joints, peripheral nerves of the limbs) — you need the skeletal framework and the course of the radial, ulnar, median, axillary, sciatic and common fibular nerves. No prior clinical orthopaedics is assumed.
The big idea
The single most useful reframing in orthopaedics is this: a fracture is a soft-tissue injury with a broken bone inside it. The bone is the part that shows on the radiograph and gets the name, but the pain, the blood loss, the swelling and the risk to the limb all come from the surrounding muscle, fascia, periosteum and vessels. That reframing explains almost every rule you are about to learn. It is why a swollen, tense limb is a surgical emergency rather than a reason to wait. It is why a long-bone fracture can lose two litres of blood into the thigh without a drop appearing outside. And it is why an open wound over a fracture is a contaminated injury treated as a wound first and a fracture second.
NoteFracture healing needs three things delivered to the fracture site: mechanical stability, an adequate blood supply, and apposition of viable bone ends (or a graft). Fail stability and you get a hypertrophic non-union; fail blood supply and you get a dry, atrophic non-union or avascular necrosis; fail apposition and the gap never bridges. Keep those three in mind and the whole of the next lesson follows.
How to describe a fracture properly
A description is not administrative box-ticking — it is how the next surgeon, reading your note six hours later, reconstructs what you saw. Six descriptors are the minimum, and in examinations they are the marks.
| Descriptor | What you record | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Which bone | Name the bone precisely, including side | Left tibia |
| Where in the bone | Proximal, middle (shaft) or distal third — or the named anatomical part | Distal third of the shaft |
| Pattern | Transverse, oblique, spiral, segmental, comminuted, impacted, compression (wedge/ crush), greenstick | Oblique |
| Displacement | The position of the distal fragment: translation, angulation (and its direction), rotation, shortening or distraction | Lateral angulation of 20°, 1 cm shortening |
| Open or closed | Whether the skin over or near the site is broken — and whether the fracture communicated with it | Closed |
| Joint involvement | Whether the fracture enters a joint (intra-articular) — this changes the prognosis | Extra-articular |
Two refinements matter. Angulation is described by the direction the distal fragment points, or by the direction of the apex of the deformity — check which convention your unit uses, because the two give opposite words for the same picture. Rotation is not visible on a radiograph at all: it is found on clinical examination, by comparing the limb's rotational profile with the other side, and it is the deformity most often missed and least often forgiven, because a malunion in rotation cannot be corrected later by anything except deliberate re-fracture.
Watch outDo not write 'compound fracture'. The word is obsolete and imprecise. 'Open fracture' is the term: it means the fracture has communicated with the outside environment. That distinction is not pedantry — an open fracture is a surgical emergency requiring wound excision, antibiotics and tetanus cover, whatever the size of the wound.
Open fractures
| Grade | Wound and soft-tissue injury | Contamination | Typical treatment |
|---|---|---|---|
| I | Clean wound under 1 cm, minimal soft-tissue damage, simple fracture pattern | Minimal | Wound excision, thorough debridement, IV antibiotics, stable fixation |
| II | Wound 1-10 cm, moderate soft-tissue injury, no extensive flap or avulsion | Moderate | As above, with closer soft-tissue assessment |
| III | Wound over 10 cm or high-energy injury with extensive soft-tissue damage whatever its size | Heavy | Debridement (often repeated), antibiotics, urgent orthopaedic and plastic input; fix or span depending on the zone of injury |
Watch outThe open-fracture rules that are never negotiable: photograph and cover the wound with a saline-soaked dressing, give IV antibiotics and tetanus prophylaxis, take the patient to theatre for wound excision and debridement (usually within six hours), and never let a wound closed in the emergency department over a fracture. Never probe or irrigate a wound before the surgeon sees it — you can drive contamination deeper and destroy the tissue you need to assess.
Common patterns and how they are made
The pattern on the film tells you the mechanism, and the mechanism tells you what else to look for. A transverse fracture from a direct blow looks nothing like a spiral fracture from a twisting injury, and the second one carries the added risk that the same rotary force tore a ligament somewhere else.
| Pattern | Mechanism | Typical setting | What to look for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Transverse | Direct blow, three-point bending | Blunt trauma; a fall onto a hard edge | Compartment syndrome; the other bone of the pair |
| Oblique | Angulation plus compression | Fall from a height, motorcycle crash | Adjacent bones and the joint above |
| Spiral | Torsional (rotational) force on a fixed foot | Skiing, football tackle, a foot caught in a hole | The child under walking age: non-accidental injury |
| Comminuted | High-energy direct force | Road traffic collision, fall from height | Chest, abdomen and pelvis — a triage problem |
| Segmental | A direct blow at a point where the bone is fixed at both ends | Direct impact to a long bone | The intervening fragment loses its blood supply |
| Stress (fatigue) | Repetitive submaximal load, normal bone | Marching, running, the second metatarsal | Normal early films; MRI or bone scan |
| Pathological | Trivial force through diseased bone | Metastasis, myeloma, osteoporosis, a simple cyst | The underlying disease — the fracture is the symptom |
| Greenstick | Bending of pliable paediatric bone; one cortex breaks, the other buckles | Falls in young children | Plastic deformation: the bone bends without any visible crack |
A two-month-old is brought in with a crying, swollen thigh, and the film shows a spiral fracture of the femoral shaft. In an infant who is not yet walking there is no mechanism for this — a fall from a surface cannot spin a femur. A spiral long-bone fracture in a non-ambulant child remains one of the classic sentinel injuries of physical abuse, and it triggers a safeguarding referral and a skeletal survey in a centre equipped for it, alongside the obvious differential of osteogenesis imperfecta.
Dislocations and fracture-dislocations
A dislocated joint is an emergency for one reason that has nothing to do with the joint: the structures that cross it — nerves, and in some joints the artery — are stretched over the displaced bone. Reduction relieves that stretch, and every minute counts, because a nerve compressed for a day behaves differently from a nerve stretched for an hour.
| Joint | Mechanism | Deformity | Structure at risk | The tell-tale sign |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Shoulder (anterior, subcoracoid) | Abduction, external rotation and extension — a fall or a tackle | Loss of the rounded shoulder contour; the arm held slightly abducted | Axillary nerve (and the posterior humeral circumflex artery) | Numb over the regimental badge patch; deltoid cannot contract |
| Hip (posterior) | Dashboard injury — a flexed knee hits the dashboard | Limb shortened, adducted, internally rotated | Sciatic nerve, especially its common fibular division | Foot drop; 10-20% of posterior dislocations injure the nerve |
| Knee (posterior) | Dashboard injury with a hyperextension force | Fixed flexion, gross deformity | Popliteal artery — a limb-threatening injury | Distal pulses, capillary refill, and a CT angiogram if any doubt |
| Elbow (posterior) | Fall onto an outstretched hand with the elbow extended | Swollen, fixed elbow; the olecranon prominent | Brachial artery and the median, ulnar and radial nerves | Hand perfusion and each nerve's territory and movement |
Watch outA posterior hip dislocation with absent foot pulses or a sciatic palsy must be reduced as an emergency, ideally under general anaesthesia within six hours. The reason is the blood supply: the retinacular vessels that climb the femoral neck are kinked by the displaced head, and every hour of displacement converts another proportion of patients onto the avascular-necrosis pathway.
A 70-year-old woman falls on her outstretched right hand and cannot use the arm. On examination the shoulder contour is flattened and there is a patch of numbness over the regimental badge area. What has happened, and what will you find on testing?
Examining a suspected fracture
The examination answers four questions in order, and the order matters. You look before you touch, and you feel before you move, because the movement is where you can do the damage.
| Step | What you do | What it tells you |
|---|---|---|
| Look | Expose both limbs fully; compare with the other side | Deformity, swelling, bruising, wounds, colour, and the rotational profile that a film cannot show |
| Feel | Palpate gently from the periphery inwards, then the pulses | Warmth, capillary refill, and the point of maximal tenderness — which localises the fracture better than the radiograph |
| Move | Active movement first, then gentle passive; never force a deformity | Whether the patient can use the limb, and the tendon and nerve function you must document |
| Neurovascular | Name each nerve's motor and sensory territory and test it; palpate the pulses | The record that protects the limb: it is the baseline against which a later deterioration is judged |
NoteThe first examination you do is a baseline, not a diagnosis. A limb documented as having intact sensation in the first dorsal web space, normal extension of the wrist and fingers, and a palpable dorsalis pedis pulse at 09:00 gives the next clinician something to compare against at 21:00. An unrecorded limb gives them nothing, and the diagnosis of compartment syndrome is then argued from memory.
Management: reduce, hold, rehabilitate
Every fracture treatment, from a buddy-strapped finger to a pelvic fixator, answers the same three questions in the same order. Nothing else in this subject is needed to organise your thinking on the ward.
| Aim | What it means | How it is achieved | When it is wrong |
|---|---|---|---|
| Reduce | Restore length, alignment and rotation; restore the joint surface if the fracture enters it | Closed manipulation under anaesthesia; open reduction; or no reduction at all for an acceptable position | Surgery to a position you could have reached with a cast — exposing the patient to the risks of an operation for no gain |
| Hold | Keep the reduction until the bone heals | Cast or slab; sling; traction; external fixator; internal fixation (plate, screw, wire, intramedullary nail) | A fixation that is too stiff to allow the micro-movement that drives callus, or a cast that is not split in a swelling limb |
| Rehabilitate | Bring back the joints, the muscles and the patient's function | Early joint movement and physiotherapy, walking aids, graded return to load, occupational therapy | Immobilising the joint that is not broken — the commonest cause of a stiff limb after a healed fracture |
The decision to operate is not a decision to treat better; it is a decision that the position cannot be reached or held by closed means, or that the joint surface is stepped, or that early movement of the joint is worth an operation. Absolute indications for internal fixation are the ones where the outcome is predictably unacceptable without it: open fractures, intra-articular fractures with a step in the joint surface, displaced fractures of the femoral neck and of the scaphoid, and fractures with an associated vascular injury.
NoteThe word 'acceptable' is doing enormous work in that table. A fracture of the shaft of the humerus with 15° of angulation and full overlap heals into a perfectly functionable arm — the shoulder is a ball joint that compensates. The same 15° of angulation in the tibia, where the bone lies directly under the skin and the ankle is a hinge, is an unacceptable malunion. Acceptability is decided by the bone, the joint above, the joint below, and the patient's demands — never by a universal number.
The five complications that must not be missed
| Complication | How it presents | What is lost by waiting |
|---|---|---|
| Compartment syndrome | Pain out of proportion, pain on passive stretch, tense swelling, paraesthesia — pulses late | Irreversible muscle necrosis within hours, myoglobinuric renal failure, Volkmann's contracture |
| Vascular injury | Absent pulse, pallor, cold limb, expanding haematoma, bruit | Limb ischaemia: irreversible damage after roughly six hours of warm ischaemia |
| Nerve injury | Numbness in a named territory, or a lost movement | The distinction neuropraxia versus axonotmesis versus neurotmesis, which is only examinable at the time of injury |
| Open fracture contamination | A wound near or over the fracture | Established deep infection of bone; a wound closed over a fracture is the classic error |
| Deep vein thrombosis | Calf pain and swelling, low-grade fever after admission | Pulmonary embolism — the commonest cause of preventable death after hip fracture |
Watch outNever accept a pulse as evidence that there is no compartment syndrome. Intracompartmental pressure rises from below the systolic at which the pulse disappears; the pulse is the last thing to go, and it usually vanishes only after the muscle is already dead. The five clinical Ps — pain (especially on passive stretch), pallor, paraesthesia, paralysis and pulselessness — are useful, but the first two are the ones you act on.
Common mistakes
Watch outDescribing a fracture only by its pattern. 'Spiral fracture of the tibia' is not a description; 'closed spiral fracture of the distal third of the left tibial shaft with 20° lateral angulation and no joint involvement' is. The pattern is one of six descriptors, and in a written answer the other five are where the marks are.
Watch outAssuming a small wound over a fracture means a small injury. An open fracture grade is determined by the energy and the soft-tissue damage, not by the size of the hole in the skin — a 1.5 cm puncture wound over a grossly comminuted tibial fracture from a bumper is a grade III injury, whatever it looks like.
Watch outMoving a grossly deformed limb to 'test the joint' before the radiograph or the nerve exam. You can convert a closed fracture into an open one, and you can convert a recovering nerve injury into a permanent one. The rule is look, feel, move — in that order, and gently.
Watch outForgetting to examine the joint above and below the fracture. A transverse fracture of the tibial shaft from a twisting injury has usually torn a knee or ankle ligament in the same accident, and a fracture of the calcaneus has usually broken a lumbar vertebra. Fractures travel.
Check your understanding
Why is the description 'comminuted fracture' insufficient, and what is the minimum you should record?
A patient has an anterior dislocation of the shoulder. What is the specific nerve you must test, what motor and sensory findings its injury produces, and why this joint in particular?
A fracture is described as 'unacceptably displaced'. Who decides what is unacceptable, and on what grounds?
Multiple choice
A restrained passenger in a head-on collision has a hip held in flexion, adduction and internal rotation. Which nerve is most at risk, and what deficit would its injury produce?
Which of the following is the correct description of an open fracture?
A patient has a fracture but a palpable distal pulse. Which statement about compartment syndrome is correct?