⚡ Rapid revision — the 20-minute version
| Spine | The mark |
|---|---|
| The cycle | Iterative — test findings feed the next iteration; a straight line is a failed story |
| Specification | Measurable and testable — 'attractive' is not a criterion |
| Research | Percentiles, not averages — the average fits nobody at the extremes |
| Materials | Property + justification for THIS use — acrylic for rigidity, aluminium for light |
| Manufacturing | Scale decides tooling — batch uses jigs; mass automates |
| Evaluation | Criterion → result → cause → change — a to-do list for version two |
1. The design cycle — a loop, not a line
Design process: BRIEF (the problem, in the client's words) → RESEARCH (users, existing products, context) → SPECIFICATION (measurable targets) → IDEAS (diverge — many, quick, unjudged) → DEVELOP (converge — refine the best) → PROTOTYPE → MAKE → TEST against the specification → EVALUATE → (loop back: findings change the design). The cycle is ITERATIVE: evaluation feeds the next round — a design that never loops is a design that never improves.
Worked: a phone stand fails the stability test (it tips) → evaluation says the base is too light → loop back and widen the footprint in development. 'What happens after testing reveals a fault?' — return to development with the finding; that loop IS the process mark.
2. Brief and specification — the problem and its rulers
Specification: The BRIEF states the problem and the client's intent ('a desk lamp for a student'). The SPECIFICATION converts it into MEASURABLE criteria the design will be judged by: aesthetic, cost, size, weight, function, safety, materials, lifespan, maintenance, sustainability. Every criterion should be testable — 'attractive' is not; 'appeals to 14–18 year-olds per survey of 20' is. You design TO the specification and evaluate AGAINST it — the same ruler both ways.
Worked: brief → specification: 'costs under 5,000 naira', 'fits a 60 cm desk depth', 'operates one-handed', 'weighs under 800 g'. At evaluation each is a pass/fail check, not a feeling. 'Write two specification points' = specific, measurable, relevant — vagueness is the mark-loser.
3. Research — designing from evidence, not assumption
| Research type | Method | What it yields |
|---|---|---|
| User research | Interviews, questionnaires, observation | Real needs and pain points |
| Product analysis | Take apart / compare existing products | What works, what fails, the gap to exploit |
| Anthropometrics | Body measurement data (percentiles) | Sizes that fit the 5th–95th percentile user |
| Ergonomics | Human factors: grip, reach, posture | Comfort and safety designed in |
| Materials research | Properties, costs, availability | A shortlist with reasons |
Ergonomics = fitting the product to the human (never the reverse). Anthropometrics uses percentiles so the small and the large are both served — designing for the 'average' excludes real people. 'Why percentiles?' — because averages fit almost nobody at the extremes; the reasoning is the mark.
4. Idea generation and development — diverge, then converge
IDEA PHASE: many sketches, annotated, judged against the specification — quantity first, quality later; even failed ideas document thinking. DEVELOPMENT: pick 2–3, model them (card, foam, clay — or CAD), test at low cost, refine proportions and joints, record WHY choices were made. Annotations carry the marks: a sketch without notes is a picture; a sketch with reasons is a design decision.
Worked: 8 quick concept sketches, each with two annotated pros/cons; shortlist against the spec; a card model of the best two reveals the thumb-grip fails at scale — refine and record. 'Show how your design developed' = the paper trail of decisions; the WHYs are the marks.
5. Materials — properties decide the choice
| Family | Examples | Choose when you need |
|---|---|---|
| Woods | Pine, oak, plywood, MDF | Warmth, workability, strength-to-cost (plywood: stable, no grain weakness) |
| Metals | Mild steel, aluminium, copper | Strength, conductivity, precision (aluminium: light + corrosion-resistant) |
| Polymers | Acrylic, ABS, polythene | Light weight, colour, mass production (polythene: tough, flexible, cheap) |
| Composites/textiles | GRP, cotton, nylon | Tailored strength or drape |
Selection = property + justification: 'acrylic for the guard — rigid, transparent, laser-cuttable' beats 'plastic because it is plastic'. Physical properties (strength, hardness, toughness, elasticity), working properties (malleability, ductility, machinability), and the cost/availability context all belong in the answer.
6. Manufacturing — the scale sets the method
Production scales: ONE-OFF (prototype, bespoke — hand tools, skilled labour), BATCH (tens–thousands — jigs and templates, seasonal products), MASS (millions — assembly lines, automation, interchangeable parts), CONTINUOUS (24/7 — steel, cement, chemicals). As volume rises, unit cost falls but tooling cost rises; quality control shifts from craftsman to process. 'Which scale for a school charity badge run?' — batch: jigs pay for themselves at tens-to-thousands, mass tooling does not.
Worked: a jig holds the work and guides the tool — every badge hole identical, unskilled assembly viable. That is why batch/mass use jigs: consistency and speed from tooling, not skill. Name the scale + the tooling logic; the logic is the mark.
7. Sustainability — the 6Rs and the lifecycle
6Rs: REDUCE (less material, less energy), REUSE (design for repeated use), RECYCLE (single-polymer parts, marked for sorting), RETHINK (does the product need to exist this way?), REPAIR (fixable joints, spares available), REFUSE (say no to the disposable version). Think the whole LIFECYCLE: raw material → manufacture → transport → use → disposal. The trap: 'recyclable' on the label means nothing if the local system cannot recycle it — design for the REAL end of life.
Worked: a bottle of mixed materials (plastic + glued paper + metal spring) cannot be sorted — a single-polymer bottle with a removable paper sleeve can. 'Make it more sustainable' = a named 6R applied to a named part; the specificity is the mark, 'use less plastic' alone is not.
8. Testing and evaluation — judge against the ruler you set
TESTING is objective: does the product meet each specification point (destructive tests — to failure; non-destructive — within use)? USER TRIALS put it in real hands and surface the things designers cannot see. EVALUATION answers honestly: which criteria passed, which failed, WHY, and what the NEXT iteration changes. A good evaluation is a to-do list for version two — claiming success without evidence is the classic failure.
Worked: spec point 'weighs under 800 g' → scale reads 860 g → FAIL, cause: solid steel base → next iteration: aluminium base, projected 620 g. Criterion → result → cause → change: the four-part chain is the evaluation mark.
9. Summary — the design & technology spine
| Question type | Method beat | Trap |
|---|---|---|
| Process | Iterative loop — findings feed back | A straight line is a failed design story |
| Specification | Measurable, testable criteria | 'Attractive' is not a criterion |
| Research | Percentiles, ergonomics, product teardown | Averages exclude the extremes |
| Materials | Property + justification for THIS use | Material without a reason earns half |
| Manufacturing | Scale decides tooling and cost | Jigs buy consistency at batch/mass scale |
| Evaluation | Criterion → result → cause → change | Honest failures score; fake wins do not |
Command discipline: 'design' = annotated decisions, reasons visible; 'justify' = property/criterion + evidence; 'evaluate' = against YOUR specification, pass/fail with causes; 'explain' = the mechanism (why jigs, why percentiles). DT papers pay for the REASONING chain — a drawing without annotations is decoration, not design.