Learning outcomes
By the end of this lesson you should be able to: distinguish normal anxiety from the anxiety disorders and state the duration, symptom-count and functional criteria that separate them; diagnose generalised anxiety disorder, panic disorder, agoraphobia, specific phobia, social anxiety disorder and obsessive-compulsive disorder; explain the acquisition and maintenance of each in terms of classical conditioning, avoidance learning and the cognitive factors of responsibility, thought-action fusion and intolerance of uncertainty; and outline first-line management, including exposure and response prevention, selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors, and the cautious role of benzodiazepines.
Prerequisites
Lesson 2 (Learning and cognition) for conditioning and the two-factor avoidance model, and Lesson 9 (Depressive disorders) for the comorbidity that alters treatment.
The big idea
Anxiety is the normal and necessary machinery of anticipating danger. Anxiety disorders arise when the same machinery runs at the wrong magnitude, in the wrong context, or for the wrong duration, and when the patient's own attempts to shut it down make it persist. Every disorder in this lesson is a variation on that theme, and every effective treatment works by interrupting the self-maintaining loop — usually by requiring the patient to stay with the anxiety rather than to remove it.
| Disorder | Core content | Threshold |
|---|---|---|
| Generalised anxiety disorder | Excessive, difficult-to-control worry about multiple domains, with autonomic hyperactivity | Most days for at least six months, with at least three of restlessness, fatigability, poor concentration, irritability, muscle tension and disturbed sleep |
| Panic disorder | Recurrent unexpected surges of fear with physical symptoms, followed by persistent concern or behavioural change | Recurrent unexpected attacks plus at least one month of persistent worry about further attacks or a change in behaviour because of them |
| Agoraphobia | Fear and avoidance of situations where escape would be difficult or help unavailable | Marked fear or avoidance in at least two of: public transport, open spaces, enclosed places, crowds, being outside alone |
| Specific phobia | Marked, immediate fear of a particular object or situation | Persistent for at least six months, with avoidance or endurance with intense fear |
| Social anxiety disorder | Marked fear of scrutiny, embarrassment or humiliation in social situations | Persistent for at least six months, with avoidance or endurance with intense anxiety |
| Obsessive-compulsive disorder | Persistent intrusive thoughts or images, and repetitive behaviours or mental acts performed to neutralise them | Time-consuming, distressing, and interfering with function, with retained insight in most patients |
Generalised anxiety disorder
The defining feature is free-floating worry: not one catastrophised object but several — finances, family, health, minor decisions — each considered in turn and none resolved. ICD-11 describes apprehension about everyday problems plus tension and motor restlessness, and DSM-5 specifies difficulty controlling the worry. The associated features are fatigue, poor concentration, irritability, muscle tension and disturbed sleep, and the physical presentation is dominated by autonomic arousal: palpitations, tremor, sweating, dry mouth, frequency of micturition and breathlessness, which is what brings the patient to a cardiologist more often than to a psychiatrist.
Watch outA patient with breathlessness, palpitations and dizziness has not failed a cardiology assessment until the cardiac, respiratory, haematological, endocrine and drug causes have been considered and the picture has been understood in context. Thyrotoxicosis, phaeochromocytoma, blood loss, anaemia, the parasympathomimetic effects of beta-agonists and pure nicotine withdrawal all present this way.
Panic disorder
A panic attack is an abrupt surge of fear that peaks within minutes and carries at least four of the following: palpitations, sweating, trembling, feelings of breathlessness, choking, chest pain, nausea, dizziness, chills or hot flushes, paraesthesia, derealisation or depersonalisation, fear of losing control, and fear of dying.
The learning sequence is the classic two-factor account: the first attack is genuinely physiological and often unexplained, and the patient's interpretation that it is catastrophic ('I am having a heart attack', 'I am going mad') drives the physical arousal upward. The bodily sensations then become conditioned stimuli for further panic, and avoidance of anything associated with an attack is negatively reinforced by the relief it brings. Nocturnal panic attacks occur on waking, in the transition between sleep stages, and are typically mistaken for nightmares; anticipatory anxiety, between attacks, becomes the disabling part of the condition.
NoteHyperventilation is the amplifier to target in treatment. Rapid breathing lowers arterial carbon dioxide, causing paraesthesia in the hands and around the mouth, dizziness, tetany and a sense of suffocation — sensations indistinguishable from the onset of panic, which drives further hyperventilation. Teaching slow diaphragmatic breathing with a prolonged out-breath breaks this loop, but it must be delivered alongside interoceptive exposure, because it is the tolerance of the sensations that resolves the disorder.
Phobic disorders and social anxiety
| Disorder | Feared object | Avoidance | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Specific phobia: animal | Snakes, spiders, dogs, insects | Avoids the animal and places where it might occur | Snakes and spiders are the commonest; the prepared-learning account holds that these are evolutionarily salient and therefore acquired faster |
| Specific phobia: natural environment | Heights, water, storms | Avoids the setting | Height phobia is the most disabling of the specific phobias |
| Specific phobia: situational | Aeroplanes, lifts, tunnels, enclosed spaces | Avoids transport, buildings and travel | Claustrophobia overlaps strongly with agoraphobia and responds to exposure |
| Blood-injection-injury phobia | Blood, needles, injury, medical procedures | Avoids dental and medical care, and pregnancy care in extreme cases | Unique among phobias: the response is vasovagal, with a fall in heart rate and blood pressure, and fainting is common. Applied tension, which raises blood pressure, is the treatment of choice — exposure alone can worsen it |
| Social anxiety disorder | Social situations, performance, and being observed | Avoids parties, public speaking, eating out, interviews, and phone calls | Usually begins in adolescence. Most people with it are convinced their anxiety is visible, and it is far less visible than they suppose |
Watch outDo not mistake normal embarrassment for a disorder. Sweating, blushing and hesitation before speaking in public are ordinary. The disorder requires marked and persistent fear that is disproportionate to the situation and causes avoidance or intense distress. Conversely, do not dismiss social anxiety in a bright and socially fluent patient: presentation in public settings often coexists with pathological private fear.
Obsessive-compulsive disorder
| Differential | Feature | Why it is not OCD |
|---|---|---|
| Obsessive-compulsive personality disorder | Preoccupation with order, control and perfection, without resistance to the pattern | Ego-syntonic: the person regards the traits as reasonable, whereas obsessions are unwanted and resisted |
| Delusional disorder | A fixed false belief with no recognition of excess | Insight is intact in most OCD; in some patients insight is poor, and the clinical response to treatment then becomes the discriminator |
| Psychosis | Delusional convictions or hallucinations without recognition of their nature | An insight question resolves the boundary directly |
| Tic disorders | Motor or vocal tics with a premonitory urge, relieved by the movement | Tics are executed to discharge tension; compulsions are executed to neutralise a threat or to prevent an event |
| Depression, anxiety, hypochondriasis and eating disorders | Recurrent ruminations and checking that resemble rituals | Ask whether the behaviours are performed to prevent harm or to neutralise distress; if they are habitual decision-making anxiety, the treatment is not exposure |
| Substance-related and neurological causes | Rituals emerging after amphetamine, cocaine or cocaine-withdrawal psychosis | Temporal course, substance timing and neurological examination |
NoteThe three cognitive maintenance factors, identified by the Obsessive Compulsive Cognitions Working Group, are worth learning because they explain the treatment: an inflated sense of responsibility and an overestimation of threat (I am responsible for preventing harm), thought-action fusion (having the thought is morally equivalent to doing the act, or makes it more likely), perfectionism and intolerance of uncertainty (the only acceptable action is certainty). Exposure and response prevention attacks each in turn — by requiring the patient to hold uncertainty, to accept responsibility, and to permit the thought without acting.
Aetiology: conditioning plus cognition
The behavioural account is Lesson 2's two-factor theory, stated in its modern form. Fear is acquired by classical conditioning; the response is maintained by negative reinforcement through avoidance, and every avoidance removes the disconfirmation that the feared outcome will not occur. Preparedness theory, proposed by Seligman, accounts for why phobias cluster on snakes, spiders and heights: organisms acquire fear of evolutionarily relevant stimuli more rapidly and more durably than of modern ones prepared by conditioning experiments in the laboratory.
The cognitive contribution is the interpretative step. A palpitation is a bodily event; the belief that it signifies death is what converts it into a panic attack. A thought of pushing someone onto a railway track is an intrusion; the belief that thinking makes doing it more likely is what makes it an obsession. Anxiety disorders therefore have two routes to change: the behavioural route of exposure, which corrects the expectation directly, and the cognitive route of examining and testing the belief, which does the same work through inference.
Developmental and familial factors contribute: behavioural inhibition in infancy (Lesson 4), an anxious and overprotective attachment style, parental modelling of anxious responses, parental control, and a specific contribution to anxiety disorders of moderate heritability, with little evidence that either traumatic conditioning or genes suffice alone. In OCD, family studies show elevated rates of obsessive-compulsive disorder in relatives of probands, and neuroimaging of the cortico-striato-thalamo-cortical loop is the standard neurobiological model, though it is a research model rather than a clinical tool.
Management
The order of treatment is clear in evidence terms: graded exposure and response prevention for the phobic and obsessive disorders, cognitive therapy for the cognitive disorders, and selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors where the disorders are moderate to severe or where psychological treatment is unavailable, declined or insufficient. Combining the two is better than either alone in more severe cases.
| Disorder | Psychological treatment | Pharmacological treatment | Practical notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Specific phobia | In vivo graded exposure with response prevention; applied tension for blood-injection-injury phobia | Rarely required; beta-blockers may be used for performance anxiety | Exposure can be delivered in a few sessions, and the strongest predictor of success is the patient remaining in the situation until anxiety falls, not escaping it |
| Panic disorder | Cognitive restructuring of catastrophic misinterpretation, interoceptive exposure and then in vivo exposure of avoided situations | SSRIs (sertraline, escitalopram, fluoxetine, paroxetine), with clomipramine second-line | Benzodiazepines suppress the panic and therefore block the exposure that resolves it; never combine with an SSRI without discussing serotonin syndrome and sedation |
| Agoraphobia | Graded exposure with response prevention, or self-exposure programmes and bibliotherapy with therapist contact | SSRIs where severe, particularly where panic is prominent | The treatment is time-consuming but durable; drop-out is the main obstacle |
| Social anxiety disorder | Cognitive therapy targeting self-focused attention and the feared evaluation, plus social exposure | SSRIs; beta-blockers for performance situations only | Group cognitive therapy has specific advantages: the group is itself a graded social exposure |
| Generalised anxiety disorder | Cognitive therapy, applied relaxation, and worry time with problem-solving | SSRIs, serotonin and noradrenaline reuptake inhibitors, buspirone, and pregabalin in some guidelines | Benzodiazepines produce rapid relief but no durable benefit and significant harm; a fixed two- to four-week prescription with a taper plan is the outside limit |
| Obsessive-compulsive disorder | Exposure and response prevention is the specific and first-line treatment; cognitive techniques for the maintenance beliefs | SSRIs at higher doses than for depression (for example fluoxetine 40-80 mg), clomipramine second-line; augmentation with an antipsychotic in treatment-resistant cases | Response requires eight to twelve weeks at adequate dose and dose, which is roughly twice the duration used in depression |
Watch outReassurance is the maintenance factor, not the treatment. Checking the lock again, calling the doctor for the fourth time, or asking a partner whether you smell of the feared substance removes anxiety today and preserves the disorder for the next decade. Where reassurance is part of the presentation, response prevention means withholding it — and this must be planned with family members as well as with the patient.
Watch outBenzodiazepines are not a treatment for anxiety disorders; they are a treatment for the sister symptom of fear. Tolerance and dependence follow within weeks, discontinuation produces rebound anxiety worse than the original, fall and fracture risk rises in the elderly, disinhibition and paradoxical aggression occur, and in combination with opioids respiratory depression is potentially fatal. Prescribe short courses for crises with a written taper plan, or not at all, and never initiate maintenance benzodiazepines.
Common mistakes
Watch outDiagnosing panic disorder on the basis of a panic attack. Panic attacks occur in anxiety, in depression, in phobic encounters with the feared object, during withdrawal, and as isolated events in healthy people. The disorder requires recurrent unexpected attacks, at least a month of consequent worrying or behavioural change, and the exclusion of organic causes; a single attack with a subsequent avoidance is not panic disorder.
Watch outMistaking agoraphobic avoidance for laziness, introversion or constitutional shyness. The consequence is a shrinking life with secondary loss, and repeated misinterpretation by others compounds the disability. Note also that avoidance is itself a barrier to recovery, so it is the specific target of treatment rather than a symptom to be sympathised with.
Watch outReading OCD as a condition of patients who need reassurance. The rituals are performed to neutralise anxiety, and providing reassurance removes the very exposure that would otherwise disconfirm the belief. Worse, telling a patient to 'stop worrying about it' mistakes an ego-dystonic disorder for an ego-syntonic disposition.
Check your understanding
A patient checks the front door eleven times before leaving. He knows it is irrational, dreads the morning, and says the thought 'what if the house burns down' arrives unbidden forty times a day. What is the diagnosis, what maintains it, and what is the first-line treatment?
Why is applied tension, rather than standard exposure, first-line for blood-injection-injury phobia?
Which cognitive maintenance factor allows an intrusive, violent thought to become an obsessive one rather than an idle one?
Summary and next
Anxiety disorders differ in content and duration rather than in mechanism. They are acquired through conditioning, amplified by catastrophic misinterpretation, and maintained by avoidance and reassurance, which remove the disconfirmation that would resolve them. The effective treatments are therefore graded exposure with response prevention, cognitive therapy for the safety beliefs, and selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors where the severity requires them; benzodiazepines buy days and cost months.
Next: somatoform and dissociative disorders. You will see what happens when distress is expressed through the body rather than the mind, and how the empathy of the clinician is itself a treatment variable.
Multiple choice
Which minimum duration is required for generalised anxiety disorder?
Which of the following is required for panic disorder rather than a panic attack alone?
What does exposure and response prevention mean in the treatment of obsessive-compulsive disorder?
A patient with severe panic attacks asks for diazepam to take as needed. What is the correct position?
Which statement about specific phobia of blood and injections is correct?