Learning outcomes
By the end of this lesson you should be able to: explain what a vaccine does and which property of the adaptive immune system it exploits; distinguish the live attenuated, inactivated, subunit and conjugate vaccine classes with an example of each; state why the measles, mumps and rubella vaccine is given at twelve months rather than at birth; explain the relationship between antigenic drift and antigenic shift and the need for annual influenza immunisation; define the herd immunity threshold and how it is calculated from the basic reproduction number; and state the consequence of falling vaccination coverage for a population.
Prerequisites
Lesson 11 (innate and adaptive immunity), because a vaccine is a controlled exposure that deliberately builds the memory that lesson described.
The big idea
Everything about vaccine design follows from one fact: the memory cells of the adaptive system last for years, but the primary response takes days. So the problem is not how to make an immune response, which the body does naturally — it is how to make the response without causing the disease. Vaccines differ only in how they solve that trade between safety and the strength of the response.
| Class | How it is made | Strength of response | Principal risk | Example |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Live attenuated | The pathogen grown so that it has lost virulence but still replicates | Strongest, closest to natural infection, and long lasting | It can revert, so it is unsafe in severe immunodeficiency and in pregnancy | Measles, mumps, rubella, the oral typhoid and the BCG vaccines |
| Inactivated | The pathogen killed physically or chemically | Weaker, so several doses or a booster are needed | It cannot cause disease at all | The injectable polio vaccine, the hepatitis A and rabies vaccines |
| Subunit or recombinant | Only a single protein or polysaccharide of the pathogen, often made by recombinant technology | Good for the protein chosen, narrower than the whole pathogen | It cannot cause disease | The hepatitis B, the human papillomavirus and the acellular pertussis vaccines |
| Conjugate | A bacterial polysaccharide chemically joined to a carrier protein | Overcomes the poor infant response to pure polysaccharide | None beyond those of any injected protein | Haemophilus influenzae type b, meningococcal and pneumococcal conjugate vaccines |
NoteThe conjugate trick is worth understanding, because it solved a real paediatric problem. A pure bacterial polysaccharide produces a weak, T cell independent response in infants under two years old — the age group at greatest risk of the invasive disease. Linking the sugar to a protein recruits the T cell help that a polysaccharide alone cannot recruit, so the vaccine works from two months of age.
Worked example: why measles vaccine waits
The reasoning is the same for measles and for the whole primary infant schedule. Maternal antibody crosses the placenta in the third trimester and gives the infant protection for the first months of life. It also, however, neutralises the live attenuated measles virus in the vaccine, so a dose given too early simply does not take. The dose is therefore timed to fall after the maternal antibody has waned but before the child is exposed to the wild virus.
| Stage | What is present | Consequence for vaccination |
|---|---|---|
| At birth | Maternal IgG against measles | The infant is protected, but the live vaccine does not work |
| By about twelve months | Maternal antibody has largely waned | The live attenuated vaccine can replicate and immunise |
| In an outbreak or in a high risk setting | Maternal antibody may persist longer in a well immunised mother | A dose is still given at nine to twelve months, accepting the reduced take |
Antigenic drift and shift
Influenza is the host for both processes, and the difference between them is the difference between a seasonal epidemic and a pandemic. Drift gives the gradual year on year change that a reformed vaccine can chase. Shift gives an entirely new virus that no existing immunity recognises, which is why pandemics arise in animals that mix influenza strains, and why surveillance of the animal reservoir is a matter of international public health.
Herd immunity
The arithmetic is simple and the consequence is severe. The threshold is one minus the inverse of the reproduction number, so an organism with a reproduction number of 18 needs about 95 per cent of the population immune, while one with a reproduction number of 3 needs about 67 per cent. Measles is the most contagious of the common vaccine preventable diseases, so its required coverage is the highest, and when coverage falls below the threshold the disease returns — which is what has happened repeatedly in Europe and in Africa in the last decade.
| Reproduction number | Herd immunity threshold | Interpretation |
|---|---|---|
| About 2 | About 50 per cent | Moderately transmissible |
| About 4 to 5 | About 75 to 80 per cent | Smallpox and poliovirus sit in this range, which is what global eradication needed |
| About 15 to 18 | About 93 to 95 per cent | Measles, which is why its coverage requirement is so high |
NoteThe threshold is a population, not an individual, statistic. It is also a statement about transmission, not about personal risk: an individual who is unvaccinated in a well vaccinated population is still protected, but that protection disappears the moment enough others decide the same thing. This is the reason the coverage figure, not the individual's choice, is what determines whether a disease can circulate.
A measles outbreak occurs in a region where 85 per cent of children received the vaccine. Why did the outbreak happen when 85 per cent coverage would control a disease with a reproduction number of 4?
Common mistakes
Watch outSaying a live attenuated vaccine can cause the disease in a healthy person. It can cause a mild, vaccine associated infection — vaccine associated paralytic poliomyelitis is the classic exception — but in a healthy recipient the response is controlled. The danger is confined to the severely immunocompromised, in whom the live organism can replicate uncontrolled.
Watch outConfusing antigenic drift with antigenic shift. Drift is the gradual mutation that needs an annual vaccine; shift is the reassortment that produces a novel virus and a pandemic.
Watch outSaying the herd immunity threshold is the same for every disease. It is one minus the reciprocal of the reproduction number, so it ranges from roughly half for a poorly transmissible organism to 95 per cent for measles.
Check your understanding
Which class of vaccine is the measles, mumps and rubella vaccine, and what is its principal contraindication?
How is a conjugate vaccine made, and what problem does it solve?
State the formula for the herd immunity threshold and the approximate value for measles.
Multiple choice
Which property of the adaptive immune system does a vaccine exploit?
Which statement about live attenuated vaccines is correct?
Which vaccine class is the hepatitis B vaccine and why?
Which change in influenza produces a pandemic rather than an annual epidemic?
A disease has a basic reproduction number of about 18. What herd immunity threshold is required?
Which disease is the prototype for a pandemic arising from antigenic shift in an animal reservoir?
Summary and next
A vaccine is a controlled first exposure that generates the memory the adaptive system already possesses. The four classes trade safety against the strength of the response — live attenuated, inactivated, subunit and conjugate — and the timing of a dose is set by the presence of maternal antibody and by the risk of exposure. Drift gives influenza its annual reformulation and shift gives it its pandemics, and the herd immunity threshold of one minus the reciprocal of the reproduction number explains why measles needs about 95 per cent coverage while a reproduction number of 4 is controlled by 75 per cent.
Next: the module closes with the clinical correlation, where the anaemias, the clots and the bleeds are brought together into bedside reasoning.