Learning outcomes
By the end of this lesson you should be able to: describe the four elements of congenital talipes equinovarus and distinguish it from the positional, correctable club-foot of the newborn; state the principles and sequence of the Ponseti method and why it is the first-line treatment; describe developmental dysplasia of the hip — its risk factors, its clinical screening with the Ortolani and Barlow tests, and the role and limits of ultrasound; explain why late-diagnosed DDH presents in the walking child with a limp and apparent shortening; describe congenital muscular torticollis and sternocleidomastoid contracture; and list the common congenital limb deficiencies and the principle of early surgical or orthotic management.
Prerequisites
Lesson 1 (Fractures & dislocations) for the vocabulary of deformity. From Gross Anatomy I: the anatomy of the hip joint and its capsule, the femoral head's blood supply, and the muscles of the thigh and the leg. No paediatric orthopaedics assumed.
The big idea
Congenital malformation is the one corner of orthopaedics where a single word distinguishes the two halves of the subject: correctable and non-correctable. A club-foot that will correct passively is positional, needs no more than gentle stretching, and has an excellent outcome. A club-foot that will not correct with any amount of gentle pressure is true congenital talipes equinovarus — a structural deformity of the bone, joint and tendon — and needs treatment that begins within days. The same distinction runs through DDH, torticollis and every other congenital condition: the first question is always 'is this a position or a structure?'
Congenital talipes equinovarus (CTEV, club-foot)
| The four elements of CTEV | What it means |
|---|---|
| Equinus | The ankle is fixed in plantarflexion, so the toes point down and the foot cannot be brought up to 90° |
| Varus | The heel is turned inward, so the sole faces towards the other foot |
| Adductus | The forefoot is turned inward relative to the hindfoot — the medial border of the foot is concave |
| Cavus | The arch is abnormally high, from the first ray being plantarflexed |
The diagnosis is clinical and it is made in the delivery room: attempt to bring the foot to a neutral position. If it corrects fully, the foot is positional (the normal result of intrauterine position at term) and needs no treatment beyond stretching. If it does not, and especially if the calf is thin, the heel is small and the medial skin creases are deep, this is true CTEV. Incidence is roughly 1 in 1,000 live births, is twice as common in boys, and is bilateral in about half of cases.
Watch outEvery child with CTEV must have both hips examined. CTEV and developmental dysplasia of the hip occur together far more often than chance, and the foot deformity distracts even an experienced examiner from the hip. This is the most common way the second diagnosis is missed.
| Stage | What is done | Why it is done in this order |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Cavus correction | The forefoot is supinated to bring the first ray up, correcting the cavus | The cavus is corrected first because a cavus foot will always adopt an adducted position to keep the ball of the foot on the ground |
| 2. Adduction and varus correction | The foot is abducted at the midfoot around the head of the talus, correcting the adduction and then the varus | The talus is the pivot; the foot is rotated around it, never pronated or twisted, because the talus is also the bone whose head is the fulcrum |
| 3. Equinus correction | The ankle is brought to dorsiflexion, with an Achilles tenotomy where it will not correct | Equinus is corrected last; the ankle is not dorsiflexed by forcing the midfoot, which would break through the arch |
| 4. Maintenance | A foot-abduction brace ( Denis Browne bar with the feet turned outwards 60-70°) worn 23 hours a day for three months, then at night until age 4-5 | Recurrence is common and is almost always caused by non-compliance with the brace |
NoteThe Ponseti method works because it treats the ligaments and not the bones: in a newborn the tarsal bones are largely cartilaginous, so a sustained gentle load remodels them. It is non-operative in about 90% of cases and it produces a supple, painless, plantigrade foot. Postero-medial soft-tissue release, the operation that preceded it, produced a stiff foot that was painful and degenerated in adult life — which is why the Ponseti method has replaced it as the first-line treatment everywhere.
A newborn has a foot that is turned down and in, with a deep medial crease, thin calf, and it cannot be passively corrected to neutral. What is the diagnosis and the first step in treatment?
Developmental dysplasia of the hip (DDH)
| Risk factor | Why it matters |
|---|---|
| Female sex | Six to eight times more common than in boys; maternal relaxin is the traditional explanation |
| Breech presentation | The commonest risk factor; the risk is highest for a frank breech (hips flexed, knees extended) |
| Family history | A first-degree relative with DDH raises the risk substantially |
| Firstborn and oligohydramnios | A tight uterus restricts the hips in extension, so the head is not seated in the socket |
| Association with other conditions | CTEV, congenital muscular torticollis, arthrogryposis, and Down syndrome all raise the risk |
Screening is by clinical examination and by selective ultrasound, and the two answer different questions. The clinical examination asks whether the hip is stable — can it be displaced? Ultrasound asks whether the femoral head is actually seated and the acetabulum is forming — an anatomical question in a hip that is clinically stable but shallow. Ultrasound before about four to six weeks gives false reassurance, because the acetabulum is still cartilaginous and shallow in every normal newborn.
| Test | Manoeuvre | What a positive test means |
|---|---|---|
| Ortolani | The hip is flexed to 90° and abducted with gentle lifting pressure on the greater trochanter | A clunk as the dislocated head reduces over the posterior lip into the socket — the sign of reduction. The Ortolani relocates |
| Barlow | The hip is flexed to 90° and adducted with gentle posterior pressure along the axis of the femur | A clunk as the head passes over the posterior lip out of the socket — the sign of provocation. The Barlow dislocates |
| Galeazzi | With the hips and knees flexed, the knees are compared | One knee is visibly lower: an apparent shortening of the femur, which in a newborn indicates a dislocated hip |
| Ortolani versus Barlow | Ortolani: reduce a dislocated hip. Barlow: dislocate a reducible hip | Confusing the two is the classic error: the Ortolani is an abduction manoeuvre and the Barlow is an adduction and posterior pressure manoeuvre |
NoteThe Ortolani and Barlow tests are gentle. They are not a stress test: the hip is flexed to 90°, the knee is flexed, and a gentle pressure is applied with the pads of the fingers. The classic exam error is performing the Barlow as a forceful push — which can injure a hip it was meant to test. The tests are also of their time: they are useful in the first few months and become unreliable after about three months, because the hip becomes less lax and the test then produces nothing more than clicks.
The late-diagnosed hip is a different disease. When the deformity is found after the child has been walking, the head has been walking outside the socket, the false acetabulum has partly formed, and the limb is shorter. These children present with a limp, with apparent shortening of the femur, with a waddling bilateral gait, and — if both hips are dislocated and the femora are driven up — with a lumbar lordosis that grows because the pelvis is tilted forward to keep the feet on the ground.
| Age at diagnosis | Presentation | Treatment |
|---|---|---|
| Newborn | A positive Ortolani (reducible) or Barlow (dislocatable) test | A Pavlik harness: the hip is held flexed and abducted, allowing the head to seat, for weeks to a few months |
| 1-6 months | A hip that does not reduce by Ortolani; ultrasound and a plain film confirm | Closed reduction under anaesthesia and a spica cast; a hip that will not reduce needs an open reduction |
| After walking age | A limp, apparent limb shortening, a waddling gait, Trendelenburg, excessive lordosis if bilateral | Open reduction with femoral and acetabular osteotomies, because the anatomy has changed and no closed method will restore a congruent joint |
Watch outThe two complications that dominate the outcome of DDH are avascular necrosis of the femoral head and residual dysplasia. Avascular necrosis can follow a reduction that was forced, a reduction that was performed in extreme abduction, or a reduction that was held too tightly for too long — so the reduction is gentle, and the position is not forced. And a hip that is reduced is not always a normal hip: acetabular development lags, and needs radiographic surveillance into childhood.
Torticollis and the other congenital conditions
| Aspect | Congenital muscular torticollis |
|---|---|
| Mechanism | Birth trauma or intrauterine position causing a haematoma and then fibrosis within the sternocleidomastoid |
| Presentation | The head is tilted to the affected side and the chin points away; a firm mass in the muscle in the infant; the head flattens on one side (positional plagiocephaly) because the child never lies flat |
| Natural history | Most resolve with stretching physiotherapy in the first year, guided by the parents |
| Surgery | A sternomastoid release (usually bipolar) if the contracture persists past 12-18 months and facial asymmetry is developing |
| The exam answer | Always exclude a neurological and an ocular cause: a child with torticollis has to have the eyes (a squint causing a head tilt) and the cervical spine examined, and Klippel-Feil and ocular causes are the differentials, not just the neck |
| Other congenital limb conditions | What it is | Key point |
|---|---|---|
| Radial club hand (radial deficiency) | Absence or hypoplasia of the radius, with the hand deviated radially; a forearm that is short and a thumb that may be absent | Look for the associated conditions: Holt-Oram (heart), VACTERL, thrombocytopenia (TAR); do not operate the shoulder |
| Ulnar deficiency | Hypoplasia of the ulna with the hand deviated toward the ulna | Less common than radial deficiency, less likely to recur, and usually a better functional outcome |
| Cleft hand (lobster claw) | A longitudinal deficiency of central rays; the hand has a deep cleft and the fingers are fused into two groups | Reconstruction aims to close the cleft and oppose the two groups, rather than to make a normal number of digits |
| Syndactyly | Fusion of adjacent digits, cutaneous (skin only) or osseous (bone shared) | Operate before the child is two, because differential growth changes the deviation of the digits; never separate a syndactyly with both sides at once on the same digit |
| Polydactyly | Supernumerary digits; pre-axial (radial, thumb side) or post-axial (ulnar, little finger side) | The extra little finger is commonest, is often a skin tag with no bone, and is amputated in the newborn period, not delayed |
| Trigger thumb | A nodule in the flexor pollicis longus tendon that catches at the A1 pulley, so the thumb is fixed in flexion | Present from birth in many cases; observation until about a year, then a release of the A1 pulley |
| Cerebral palsy (the orthopaedic consequences) | Spasticity produces equinus, adduction and internal rotation of the hip, and later a fixed contracture and hip subluxation | Early orthopaedic input is to preserve range and monitor the hip; hip surveillance is the highest-yield intervention |
NoteA recurrent theme in congenital orthopaedics is that the operation follows the growth. Syndactyly is separated early because the fingers grow at different lengths and a fused pair will deviate. A congenital trigger thumb is not released in the newborn because it often resolves. A dislocated hip that is reduced in the newborn needs a spica cast for weeks; a hip that is reduced at a year needs a different operation; a hip that is reduced at five years needs an osteotomy. The condition and the age together determine the operation.
Common mistakes
Watch outCalling a positional foot a club-foot. The diagnosis of CTEV requires the inability to correct the deformity passively. A newborn whose foot is turned in because of intrauterine position corrects fully, has a normal heel and normal calf, and needs only stretching. Diagnosing it as CTEV commits the family to months of casting that will do nothing, and raising the level of alarm for no reason.
Watch outReversing the Ortolani and Barlow manoeuvres. The Ortolani is an abduction manoeuvre: it reduces a dislocated hip, with a clunk. The Barlow is an adduction and posterior pressure manoeuvre: it dislocates a reducible hip, with a clunk. Reversing them will either fail to find the hip or, worse, dislocate a hip that was previously stable.
Watch outCasting a club-foot with the equinus corrected first. The Ponseti sequence is cavus, then adduction and varus, then equinus last (with a tenotomy if needed). Correcting the equinus first forces the midfoot to rock through, creating a rocker-bottom foot that cannot be rehabilitated.
Watch outForgetting to examine the hips of a child with a club-foot, or the neck of a child with a hip condition. CTEV and DDH coexist more often than chance, and congenital muscular torticollis must be separated from a cervical spine abnormality and a squint before the neck is treated. Congenital malformations arrive in groups, not in isolation.
Check your understanding
Name the four elements of congenital talipes equinovarus and the single clinical test that distinguishes it from a positional foot.
Describe the difference between the Ortolani and the Barlow test, and state what each detects.
Why is ultrasound not used to screen every newborn hip, and when is it useful?
Multiple choice
A newborn has a foot that is turned downward and inward with a deep medial crease and cannot be passively corrected to neutral. What is the first-line treatment?
A newborn is screened with Ortolani's and Barlow's manoeuvres. Which description of these two tests is correct?
A baby girl born in the breech position has a palpable clunk in the right hip on the Ortolani test. What is the initial treatment?