Learning outcomes
By the end of this lesson you should be able to: classify the contraceptive methods by their mechanism and give the typical and perfect-use failure rates of the principal ones; state the absolute contraindications to the combined oral contraceptive pill; name the methods that are long-acting reversible and their durations; describe the mechanisms of emergency contraception and its time windows; and counsel a patient about which method suits her circumstances.
Prerequisites
Lessons 1-3. Every contraceptive method acts on the menstrual cycle, the ovary, the tube or the uterus that you have just learned.
The big idea
The gap between typical use and perfect use is the central fact of contraceptive counselling, and it is the reason the long-acting reversible methods are the most effective. A pill taken with the same accuracy every day is over 99 per cent effective, but taken as most people take it, about 7 to 9 women in a hundred become pregnant in a year. An implant or a coil, which requires nothing of the woman after insertion, has a failure rate of well under 1 per cent regardless of adherence.
Worked example: the methods
| Method | Mechanism | Duration | Typical-use failure rate per year |
|---|---|---|---|
| Combined oral contraceptive pill | Oestrogen and progestogen suppress follicle-stimulating hormone and the luteinizing surge, so ovulation is prevented; the cervical mucus is thickened and the endometrium thinned | Daily pill | About 7 per cent |
| Progestogen-only pill | Thickens the cervical mucus and prevents ovulation, with the window of dose timing to remain 3 hours for the traditional pill | Daily pill | About 7 per cent |
| Progestogen implant | Thickens the cervical mucus, thins the endometrium, and suppresses ovulation in most users | Three years | Under 0.1 per cent |
| Depot progestogen injection | Suppresses ovulation and thickens the cervical mucus | Every three months | About 4 per cent (with the return of fertility often delayed by several months) |
| Combined transdermal patch | Oestrogen and progestogen delivered transdermally | Weekly patch | About 7 per cent |
| Combined vaginal ring | Oestrogen and progestogen delivered vaginally | Three weeks in, one week out | About 7 per cent |
| Copper intrauterine device | The copper is toxic to sperm and prevents fertilisation; it is hormone-free | Five to ten years | Under 1 per cent |
| Levonorgestrel intrauterine system | Thins the endometrium and thickens the cervical mucus; it also reduces menstrual bleeding | Eight years (or five for the smaller device) | Under 1 per cent |
| Male and female condom | A mechanical barrier | Per act | About 13 to 21 per cent, but it is the only method that also reduces sexual transmission of infection |
NoteSterilisation is more than 99 per cent effective but is intended to be permanent, and it is a surgical decision rather than a contraceptive one; the intrauterine methods are therefore the long-acting reversible options, and they are the only methods in which effectiveness does not depend on the patient's adherence.
Contraindications to the combined pill
| Contraindication | Reason |
|---|---|
| A personal history of venous thromboembolism | Oestrogen is prothrombotic |
| Current or historic breast cancer | Oestrogen-sensitive malignancy |
| Migraine with aura | An oestrogen-containing method further increases the risk of stroke |
| Smoking over the age of 35 | The combination of oestrogen, smoking and age markedly increases the risk of arterial thrombosis |
| Controlled hypertension | The oestrogen raises the blood pressure, so it is contraindicated |
| Breastfeeding within six weeks of delivery | Oestrogen reduces milk supply |
| A history of ischaemic heart disease or stroke | Prothrombotic and pro-atherogenic risk |
| Known or suspected pregnancy | The pill has nothing to treat |
The progestogen-only methods have far fewer contraindications, because they lack the thrombotic effect of oestrogen, and they are the methods of choice in the patient with migraine with aura, a history of venous thromboembolism, and breastfeeding within six weeks. The price of that safety advantage is bleeding irregularity, which is common with progestogen-only contraception.
Clinical correlation: emergency contraception
Two methods of emergency contraception exist, and both must be started as early as possible. The copper intrauterine device is the most effective, and it can be inserted up to five days after unprotected intercourse and can then be retained as the woman's ongoing contraception. Oral levonorgestrel can be taken up to 72 hours after intercourse (and is licensed for up to 120 hours for the ulipristal variant, though it is less effective), and it works mainly by delaying or inhibiting ovulation, and it does not disrupt an established pregnancy.
A patient with migraine with aura is asking for contraception. Which methods must be avoided?
Common mistakes
Watch outSaying the pill causes an abortion. The hormonal methods mainly prevent ovulation, and they do not disrupt an established pregnancy.
Watch outSaying condoms are the most effective method because they are the easiest to use. They are not the most effective, but they are the only common method that also reduces sexual transmission of infection — a separate benefit.
Watch outSaying contraception is contraindicated in all smokers. The combined oestrogen-containing method is contraindicated in smokers over 35, and not in younger smokers — where the absolute risk is lower.
Check your understanding
Why are the long-acting reversible methods more effective than the pill?
What are the absolute contraindications to the combined oral contraceptive pill?
How long after unprotected intercourse can emergency contraception still be used?
Multiple choice
Which contraceptive method has the lowest typical-use failure rate?
Which of the following is an absolute contraindication to the combined oral contraceptive pill?
What is the difference between a copper intrauterine device and a levonorgestrel intrauterine system?
For how long is a levonorgestrel intrauterine system effective?
Which is the most effective form of emergency contraception?
Summary and next
Contraception is classified by mechanism — prevention of ovulation, thickening of cervical mucus, thinning of the endometrium, sperm toxicity, or a mechanical barrier — and by duration. The combined hormonal methods are highly effective in perfect use and depend on daily or weekly adherence, while the long-acting reversible methods do not depend on adherence and are therefore the most effective. The combined pill is contraindicated in patients with migraine with aura, a venous thromboembolism, or smoking over the age of 35, and emergency contraception is the copper device or oral levonorgestrel, both acting by delaying ovulation.
Next: infertility — where the same knowledge is used to help a couple conceive, and where the initial assessment is deliberately still within the capability of a generalist.