Learning outcomes
By the end of this lesson you should be able to: define pneumonia and classify it by site of acquisition and by severity; use the CURB-65 score to decide where a patient is treated; predict the likely organism from the setting and the comorbidity; interpret a chest radiograph for consolidation, effusion and cavitation; apply Light's criteria to a pleural fluid sample; recognise a complicated parapneumonic effusion and an empyema and state their management; and manage a pneumothorax, including the immediate treatment of a tension pneumothorax.
Prerequisites
PHYS 101 (the alveolar-capillary interface, ventilation and perfusion), MED 301 lesson 4 (fever and sepsis, and the first-hour bundle), lesson 3 (acid-base and the hypoxaemia of shunt), and the microbiology of the respiratory pathogens from MICR 201.
The big idea
Consolidation is the pathological word and it explains everything clinical. The alveoli that are normally an air-filled interface with the capillary blood become a tissue-like mass, so oxygen cannot reach the blood passing through the affected segments. Blood then flows past an alveolus it cannot oxygenate, and the hypoxaemia that results is said to be refractory: raising the inspired oxygen does not fully correct it because the shunt fraction is unchanged. Fever, sputum, pleuritic pain and crackles are the visible consequences of the same alveolar flooding.
Classification
| Category | Definition | Typical pathogens | Treatment implication |
|---|---|---|---|
| Community-acquired (mild) | Acquired outside a healthcare facility, treated at home | Streptococcus pneumoniae, Haemophilus influenzae, Moraxella catarrhalis, respiratory viruses including influenza and SARS-CoV-2 | Oral amoxicillin, or a macrolide or doxycycline when a penicillin allergy or a local pattern favours it |
| Community-acquired (severe) | Community-acquired pneumonia requiring admission, usually to a monitored bed | Pneumococcus, but also Staphylococcus aureus after influenza, Legionella, Gram-negative bacilli, and atypicals | Intravenous beta-lactam plus a macrolide, and consideration of atypical and viral cover with intensive care involvement |
| Hospital-acquired (HAP) | Onset more than 48 hours after admission, and not incubating on arrival | Staphylococcus aureus including methicillin-resistant strains, Pseudomonas aeruginosa, Enterobacterales, Klebsiella | Broader Gram-negative and resistant cover, guided by local cultures and prior antibiotics |
| Ventilator-associated | Onset more than 48 hours after endotracheal intubation | The same as hospital-acquired pneumonia, with a higher burden of resistant organisms | Cultures before changing antibiotics, and the narrowest effective regimen |
| Aspiration | Inhaled gastric or oropharyngeal contents, often with a depressed swallow or consciousness | Anaerobes, Gram-negative bacilli, oral streptococci | Cover anaerobes when the aspiration is of gastric content or there is periodontal disease, abscess or putrid sputum |
| Immunocompromised host | Any pneumonia in a patient with neutropenia, HIV, transplantation or steroid therapy | Pneumocystis jirovecii, cytomegalovirus, fungi, Nocardia, tuberculosis | Wider differential, earlier empirical cover, and treatment for Pneumocystis with co-trimoxazole when suspected |
Watch outRecurrent pneumonia in the same segment, or one that fails to resolve, implies an obstruction — an endobronchial tumour, a foreign body or a narrowing — and requires bronchoscopy rather than simply a second course of antibiotics.
Severity and the place of care
| Score | Components | Interpretation |
|---|---|---|
| CURB-65 | Confusion, urea above 7 millimoles per litre, respiratory rate 30 or more, blood pressure below 90 systolic or 60 diastolic, age 65 or over — one point each | 0 to 1: low risk, treat at home. 2: consider hospital admission. 3 to 5: admit, and treat 4 or more as severe, with urgent review for critical care |
| CRB-65 (community version) | Confusion, respiratory rate, blood pressure and age, without urea | The same interpretation in general practice, where a blood urea result is not immediately available |
| Pneumonia severity index | Demographics, comorbidity, examination and laboratory values, giving low to high risk classes | A more discriminating score for the moderate-risk patient, but more complex at the bedside |
| Clinical judgement at the bedside | Oxygen saturation, respiratory rate, exhaustion, comorbidity, social support | Overrides any score: a patient with a low score and no support at home is still admitted |
The score exists to keep mild pneumonia at home and severe pneumonia in hospital, because both errors carry a risk: treating a severe pneumonia at home is fatal, and admitting a mild one exposes the patient to hospital organisms and restraints. The score does not include the patient's ability to manage at home, which is why the last row is part of the tool.
Organism clues in the history
| Clue | Likely organism | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Influenza followed by a second deterioration after a few days | Staphylococcus aureus | The influenza-damaged airway is colonised, and the organism produces toxins and cavitation |
| Age, alcohol dependence, smoking | Klebsiella pneumoniae, Haemophilus | Alcohol dependence and smoking alter the airway's defences and favour the Gram-negative flora |
| Water systems, hotel stays, travel, hyponatraemia, high fever and diarrhoea | Legionella pneumophila | It replicates in warm water, and it causes a systemic illness with hyponatraemia and deranged liver tests |
| A younger patient with a slow-onset cough, headache and malaise, with fewer chest signs than expected | Mycoplasma pneumoniae, Chlamydia | The atypical organisms cause an interstitial rather than an alveolar pattern, and a walking pneumonia |
| A bird exposure, immunocompromise, or granulomatous disease | Chlamydia psittaci, fungi, tuberculosis | The exposure history suggests the pathogen |
| A recent dental extraction, a seizure or alcohol intoxication with putrid sputum | Anaererobic infection, and an abscess or empyema | The anaerobes are the flora of the mouth and they destroy tissue |
| A high CD4 count fall, a dry cough and marked desaturation on exertion | Pneumocystis jirovecii | A fungal organism that produces an interstitial shadow with profound desaturation out of proportion to the appearances |
Investigations in the management of pneumonia
| Test | Finding | Use |
|---|---|---|
| Chest radiograph | Lobar or segmental consolidation, a lower-zone or perihilar pattern, cavitation, effusion, or diffuse interstitial change | The definitive investigation, and the one that classifies the radiographic pattern; may lag behind the clinical picture |
| Blood cultures | Positive in a minority of severe cases | Drawn before antibiotics in severe disease, and the reason to give antibiotics immediately after rather than before |
| Sputum and throat swab | A Gram stain and culture, plus a respiratory viral panel and atypical serology or urine antigens | Guides a change of therapy in the patient who fails to respond |
| Arterial blood gases | Hypoxaemia with a widened alveolar-arterial gradient, and a respiratory alkalosis that becomes an acidosis if the patient tires | Determines the need for oxygen and ventilatory support, and is essential in severe disease |
| Bloods | White cell count, CRP, procalcitonin, renal function, liver tests, electrolytes | Establishes a baseline and detects the hyponatraemia and renal impairment of Legionella, and the sepsis that accompanies the disease |
| Severity markers | Lactate, procalcitonin, and the sepsis criteria of lesson 4 | Identifies the septic patient, and the need to look for a source or complication |
NoteGive antibiotics immediately after blood cultures have been drawn, not after they are processed. The mortality of severe community-acquired pneumonia rises with every hour of delay, and no diagnostic test justifies withholding the first dose.
Failure to improve and the complications
| Reason | What to check | Action |
|---|---|---|
| Wrong diagnosis | Is there heart failure, pulmonary embolism, malignancy or a pulmonary infarct? A patient with COVID-19 or an atypical infection has a slower radiographic resolution than the clinical course | Re-examine, re-image, and reconsider the differential rather than simply extending the antibiotic course |
| Resistant or unusual organism | Culture results, prior antibiotics, immunosuppression, travel and animal exposure | Change therapy guided by culture, and cover Staphylococcus aureus, Legionella, Pneumocystis and tuberculosis as the history indicates |
| Complication | Parapneumonic effusion, empyema, lung abscess, necrotising pneumonia, deep vein thrombosis of the legs, and cerebral or pulmonary metastases of the original infection | Imaging, drainage for collections, and the treatment of the complication as the priority |
| Host factor | Immunosuppression, neutropenia, uncontrolled diabetes, malnutrition, alcohol dependence, obstructing lesion | Address the host: glucose control, nutrition, reversal of obstruction, and reconsideration of the organism |
| Complication | Recognition | Management |
|---|---|---|
| Parapneumonic effusion | A homogenous opacity in the costophrenic angle with a meniscus, and dullness with absent breath sounds and reduced tactile fremitus | Aspirate for biochemistry, microscopy and culture, and drain if the fluid is an exudate with a low pH, positive Gram stain or frank pus |
| Empyema | Frank pus in the pleural space, a raised neutrophil count and protein, and loculation on ultrasound or CT | Antibiotics plus intercostal drainage, with intrapleural fibrinolytics and surgical decortication if it fails to resolve |
| Lung abscess | Cavitation with an air-fluid level, a swinging fever, and foul sputum | Prolonged antibiotics (usually 4 to 6 weeks), drainage for a large or non-resolving abscess, and treatment of the underlying aspiration risk |
| Necrotising pneumonia | Multiple thin-walled cavities that appear within days | Antibiotics with a prolonged course, and drainage for a complicated collection |
| Acute respiratory distress syndrome | Refractory hypoxaemia with bilateral infiltrates arising within a week of the infection | Lung-protective ventilation and supportive care, and the underlying infection is the only specific treatment |
Pleural effusion: transudate or exudate
The first question of any pleural fluid is where it came from, because a transudate means the pleura is normal and the fluid has been forced out of the capillaries by hydrostatic or oncotic pressure, while an exudate means the pleura itself is diseased. Light's criteria distinguish them in three measurements, and the diagnosis then proceeds to the cause.
| Light's criterion | Value that makes the fluid an exudate |
|---|---|
| Pleural fluid protein divided by serum protein | Above 0.5 |
| Pleural fluid lactate dehydrogenase divided by serum lactate dehydrogenase | Above 0.6 |
| Pleural fluid lactate dehydrogenase | Above two thirds of the upper limit of the laboratory's normal serum value |
One criterion is enough to make the fluid an exudate; none of the three being met makes it a transudate. In the special case of a patient on diuretics for heart failure, the protein gradient may be artificially high — so a pleural fluid protein above that of the serum, or an elevated protein gradient above 3.1 grams per decilitre, supports a transudate rather than the diagnosis the Light's criteria would suggest.
| Transudate | Exudate | |
|---|---|---|
| Commonest cause | Left heart failure | Pneumonia (parapneumonic), malignancy, pulmonary embolism, tuberculosis, pancreatitis, and connective tissue disease |
| Differential list | Heart failure, cirrhosis with ascites, nephrotic syndrome, hypoalbuminaemia, constrictive pericarditis, superior vena cava obstruction | Malignancy (lung, breast, lymphoma, mesothelioma), pneumonia and empyema, pulmonary embolism, tuberculosis, rheumatoid disease, pancreatitis |
| pH | Normal at about 7.6 | Below 7.2 suggests infection or malignancy; below 7.2 with fibrinopurulent fluid is a complicated parapneumonic effusion |
| Glucose | Similar to serum | Low in empyema, rheumatoid disease, tuberculosis and malignancy |
| Cytology | Scant cells | Malignant cells are diagnostic, and are found in about 60 percent of malignant effusions |
| Management | Treat the cause; the effusion resolves with the underlying disease | Drain if symptomatic or if it is an effusion complicating infection; investigate with cytology and biopsy |
Pneumothorax
| Type | Mechanism | Management |
|---|---|---|
| Primary, spontaneous | Rupture of a subpleural bleb in a young, tall, thin patient with normal lungs | Needle aspiration if the rim is 2 centimetres or more or the patient is breathless; discharge with advice to avoid flying and diving to follow |
| Secondary, spontaneous | Rupture through diseased lung in chronic obstructive pulmonary disease or asthma | Always admitted, and more likely to need an intercostal drain because the underlying lung cannot tolerate the collapse |
| Traumatic | Rib fracture, penetrating injury, or barotrauma from ventilation | Chest drain for any traumatic pneumothorax; do not use positive pressure ventilation before the drain |
| Tension | A one-way valve effect so that air accumulates and collapses the lung and shifts the mediastinum | Immediate needle decompression in the second intercostal space in the midclavicular line (or the fifth space in the anterior axillary line), then a formal chest drain — it is a clinical diagnosis made before the radiograph |
Watch outThe signs of a tension pneumothorax are absent breath sounds on the affected side, tracheal deviation away from it, hyper-resonance, respiratory distress and hypotension — and the treatment is needle decompression, not a radiograph. Waiting for imaging is the classic and fatal error.
NoteGuidelines differ in their size thresholds and equipment, and local protocols govern the detail; the invariant principles are that any symptomatic or secondary pneumothorax is admitted, that a drain is inserted for signs of tension or failure, and that breathlessness with a raised venous pressure and deviation is decompressed first and filmed afterwards.
Common mistakes
Watch outWaiting for a chest radiograph before treating a suspected tension pneumothorax, or before giving oxygen to a hypoxaemic patient. The clinical signs are sufficient, and the delay of minutes is what determines the outcome.
Watch outDiagnosing heart failure in a patient with an effusion without checking whether the fluid is a transudate. An exudate in an elderly patient with breathlessness may be a malignancy or an embolic effusion rather than the failure it was assumed to be.
Watch outAttributing a failure to improve to antibiotic resistance alone. The commonest reasons are a wrong diagnosis, an unrecognised complication, or the presence of an obstruction — so the patient is re-examined and re-imaged rather than simply re-treated.
Watch outMissing a pneumothorax on a supine chest radiograph, where the air collects in the anterior and basal positions rather than at the apex. Look at the deep sulcus sign and the costophrenic angle on any supine trauma film.
Check your understanding
Why is the hypoxaemia of consolidation only partly corrected by a high inspired oxygen?
A 70-year-old with pneumonia has a confusion score of 10 out of 10, a urea of 9 millimoles per litre, a respiratory rate of 32, a blood pressure of 88/58 and an age of 70. What is the CURB-65 score and the disposition?
How do Light's criteria distinguish a transudate from an exudate, and what are the commonest causes of each?
Multiple choice
A 68-year-old with community-acquired pneumonia has a CURB-65 score of 3. Which disposition is appropriate?
A patient on the ward has become suddenly breathless with absent breath sounds on the right, tracheal deviation to the left and a blood pressure of 78/50. What is the immediate action?
A pleural fluid sample has a fluid to serum protein ratio of 0.65 and a low pH of 7.0 with abundant neutrophils. What is the diagnosis and the management?
Which organism is classically associated with pneumonia that develops after influenza?
A patient admitted with pneumonia has been treated for 48 hours and is not improving. Which action is most appropriate?
Module summary and next
Pneumonia is a shunt disease: the alveoli are flooded, so hypoxaemia is the life-threatening consequence and the organism is the cause. The bedside task is threefold — to score the severity and so choose the site of care, to predict the organism from the setting, and to detect the complications of effusion, empyema and abscess. The pleural space is governed by the same principle: the fluid's chemistry tells you whether it is a transudate to be treated by its cause or an exudate to be investigated and drained.
Next: pulmonary embolism — the other cause of pleuritic pain and breathlessness, in which the diagnosis rests on a probability score and the danger is in the delay.