Learning outcomes
By the end of this lesson you should be able to: state the elements of rape under the BNS and the age-based aggravations, including the changed marital exception; describe the protocol for examining a survivor of sexual violence, from consent and emergency care to evidence preservation and the seven-day report; explain the purpose and timing of each specimen collected; dismantle the medico-legal myths about the hymen, virginity and pregnancy; and describe the examination of the accused, including the significance of injuries that the survivor's resistance would produce.
Prerequisites
Lessons 1 and 6. You need consent, certificates and the reporting duty, together with the sequence of a forensic examination of the living.
The big idea
The law was rewritten in 2023 around a simple axis. Under section 63 of the BNS (formerly section 375 of the Indian Penal Code), rape is penetration of the vagina, mouth, urethra or anus with the penis, or with any object or part of the body, without consent — and the consent of a minor under eighteen years is no consent at all. Proof of penetration does not require proof of injury: the elasticity of the young hymen means that complete penetration can occur without a tear, without bleeding and without pain, and an intact hymen proves nothing either way.
| Provision | Offence and punishment |
|---|---|
| Section 63 BNS (formerly 375 IPC) | Defines rape: penetration, to any extent, without consent or under vitiated consent; the marital exception now applies only to a wife aged eighteen or above |
| Section 64 BNS (formerly 376 IPC) | Punishment: rigorous imprisonment of not less than ten years, extending to imprisonment for life, and fine |
| Section 65 BNS (formerly 376A IPC) | Rape causing death, or leaving the woman in a persistent vegetative state: rigorous imprisonment for life, or death |
| Section 70 BNS (formerly 376D IPC) | Gang rape: rape committed by more than one person acting in furtherance of a common intention |
| POCSO, 2012 | Aggravated punishment where the victim is under eighteen; special courts and special procedures |
NoteZero FIR (section 173 BNSS) applies with full force: a survivor may complain at any police station, which registers it and transfers it to the competent station. The examining doctor should therefore not delay the examination because the 'right' station has not been reached.
Examination and emergency care
Treatment comes first and the examination serves it. Serious injury, pregnancy and infection are emergencies: emergency contraception, prophylaxis against sexually transmitted infection including HIV, tetanus, hepatitis B vaccination, analgesia, and treatment for the psychological state are offered and recorded. The forensic examination proceeds only after the patient is stable enough to consent to it — and never at the cost of delay where treatment cannot wait.
| Step | Detail |
|---|---|
| Consent | Informed, written, and revisitable: the survivor may decline any part of the examination and still receive treatment; the right to a support person; the right to a female examiner |
| Examiner | A female doctor wherever practicable, with a female attendant, privacy, and a chaperone recorded in the report |
| History | The account as narrated, marked as alleged; the time, place and circumstances; whether the survivor bathed, washed, douched, changed clothes, urinated or defecated after the event |
| General examination | Demeanour, alcohol or drug signs, and any areas of injury — whole body, including mouth, breasts, thighs, buttocks and the back |
| Genital examination | External first: the labia, fourchette, fossa navicularis and perineum; internal only where indicated and with the woman's consent; a colposcope where available for magnification and documentation |
| Documentation | Photographs with consent, body diagrams, and a description of each finding with its age |
Timing is recorded because it governs the evidential value of the specimens, but an examination is never refused for lateness. Semen, saliva and the assailant's DNA are best detected within the first twenty-four to seventy-two hours; spermatozoa may persist in the cervix for several days; bruises and abrasions carry their own window of about a week for visible change. The report therefore states the interval between the alleged assault and the examination, and what the interval means for each expected finding.
Specimens and their purpose
| Specimen | Purpose | Preservation |
|---|---|---|
| Vaginal, vulval and low vaginal swabs, and a cervical swab | Spermatozoa, semen components and assailant DNA; the low vaginal swab is the higher-yield specimen in a delayed presentation | Dried on a labelled swab, or in the preservative the laboratory specifies; sealed and signed |
| Rectal and oral swabs where applicable | DNA evidence of the acts alleged | As above, with the site labelled |
| Clothing, unlaundered | Semen, blood, fibres and trace evidence; the clothes worn at the time are the best source | Dried, each item separately bagged and labelled, never mixed |
| Pubic hair and head hair combings | Assailant hair and trace transfer; also for the survivor's own comparison samples | Dried in separate labelled envelopes |
| Blood and urine | Drugs of incapacitation, pregnancy test, infection screening, DNA reference sample | Blood into fluoride or plain tubes as the protocol directs; urine in the bottles provided |
| Fingernail scrapings | DNA and skin of the assailant from resistance | Swabbed or clipped into a labelled envelope |
NoteThe laboratory confirmation of recent intercourse rests on microscopy for spermatozoa, the detection of seminal components such as acid phosphatase and prostate-specific antigen — which persist longer than sperm — and DNA profiling that can link or exclude an accused. Absence of all of them, after the window, does not exclude the offence.
Hymen, virginity and pregnancy: the myths
| Claim once made to courts | The medical evidence |
|---|---|
| An intact hymen proves no intercourse occurred | The hymen is elastic, its opening varies and it stretches without tearing; an intact hymen is compatible with completed penetration |
| A torn hymen proves intercourse occurred | Tears arise from tampons, masturbation, sport and medical examination; fresh tears must be aged and interpreted in context |
| Bleeding at first intercourse is expected | Most first acts do not bleed significantly; absence of bleeding is of no probative value |
| The two-finger test assesses virginity or sexual habit | The Supreme Court of India rejected the test in Lillu versus State of Haryana (2013) as having no bearing on the offence and being degrading; a lax vagina is not evidence of prior intercourse |
| Pregnancy proves consent and dates the offence | Pregnancy neither proves nor disproves consent; it establishes only that intercourse occurred sometime before conception, and paternity testing, not the pregnancy, links a man to it |
| Absence of injuries disproves the allegation | Injuries are frequently absent in genuine cases; injury is neither necessary nor sufficient proof of the offence |
The doctor's report is a description of findings with their significance stated medically — never a conclusion that a woman was or was not 'virgin', or that she had been 'habituated to sexual intercourse'. Those are phrases from an older jurisprudence; a modern court does not want them, and a doctor who writes them has miscast the medical role.
Examination of the accused
The accused is examined under section 51 BNSS at a police request, and under section 52 BNSS where the charge is rape — the latter requiring the consent of the accused, and a government or local-authority hospital wherever practicable. The purpose is twofold: to record injuries the accused bears, which the survivor's resistance would explain, and to take reference and trace samples from him.
| Finding on the accused | Value |
|---|---|
| Scratches on the forearms, backs of the hands, face and neck; bite marks; bruising of the knuckles | Consistent with resistance by the survivor; their absence does not exclude the offence |
| The accused's DNA in the survivor's swabs or under her fingernails | Direct evidence linking the two bodies at the time |
| Sexually transmitted infection found in the accused, and subsequently in the survivor | Circumstantial support, weighed with the timing and the baseline infection rate |
| Injuries the accused attributes to an innocent cause | The account is recorded and the injury described; consistency with the account is a medical question, guilt is not |
A survivor examined eight hours after the assault has no visible genital injury. What may the report properly say?
Common mistakes
Watch outWriting that the hymen was 'torn', that the woman was 'habituated to sexual intercourse', or that she was 'not virgin'. Such phrases are medically meaningless, legally obsolete, and they hand the defence an easy target.
Watch outBathing or changing the survivor's clothing before the samples are taken, or swabbing the vulva after the vagina. The examination follows the order of evidential loss: clothing first, external swabs before internal, and no cleaning until every specimen is collected.
Watch outRefusing or delaying the examination because the presentation is late, or because the survivor is intoxicated or dishevelled. Delay and untidy presentation are not grounds for anything; record both factually and examine what the case allows.
Check your understanding
Why does an intact hymen not exclude rape, and what should a report say instead of using the word 'virgin'?
Which specimens give the highest yield in a survivor presenting seventy-two hours after an assault, and why?
What is the significance of scratches on the forearms of the accused?
Multiple choice
Under the BNS, 2023, which statement about rape is correct?
The medical examination of a woman who alleges rape is governed by which provision and which rule?
A survivor has no genital injuries on examination. Which statement is correct?
Which of these findings on the accused is consistent with the survivor's resistance?
The two-finger test is described in court. What is its status?
Summary and next
The offence turns on consent, and penetration to any extent without it is rape under section 63 BNS, with section 64 fixing a minimum of ten years of rigorous imprisonment. The examination is consent-based, female-examiner-led wherever practicable, treats emergencies first, and preserves clothing, swabs and DNA in a documented chain; the reported interval is stated with its effect on each specimen. The hymen, virginity and pregnancy carry none of the evidential weight once claimed for them, and phrases of moral judgement have no place in the report.
Next: forensic psychiatry — responsibility, fitness, testamentary capacity and the mental-health framework that governs them.