Learning outcomes
By the end of this lesson you should be able to: describe the demographic cycle and place India in it; compute and interpret the fertility indicators (crude birth rate, total fertility rate, net reproduction rate) and the contraceptive prevalence and unmet need; classify contraceptive methods as spacing or terminal and by mechanism, and state the effectiveness, contraindications and side effects of the methods in common use; describe the counselling approaches (GATHER) used in the family welfare programme; and state the elements of India's population policy approach.
Prerequisites
Lessons 2, 5 and 9. Contraception is counselled with the behavioural frameworks of the earlier lessons, its programme is measured with the indicators of the statistics lesson, and its maternal-survival value rests on the MCH lesson above.
The big idea
Family welfare is not population control. The programme's stated target is a target-free approach in which services meet demand, and its health logic is maternal and child: a first pregnancy before 18, or a birth within months of the last, carries more danger to mother and child than the couple's question of family size suggests. Demography sets the frame — a country growing at every denominator, whether it is a school, a bed or a village water source — and contraception is where individual choice and public interest coincide most completely.
The demographic cycle
| Stage | Birth rate | Death rate | Population growth | Where it is seen |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. High stationary | High | High | Static | Pre-industrial societies |
| 2. Early expanding | High | Falling | Rapid growth | Countries that have begun public health improvements |
| 3. Late expanding | Falling | Low | Growth slows | India, most of South Asia today |
| 4. Low stationary | Low | Low | Static | Western Europe, Japan |
| 5. Declining | Very low | Very low | Shrinking | A few European countries |
| Indicator | Roughly where India stands | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|
| Crude birth rate | Close to 20 per 1,000 population | The denominator of births for every service |
| Total fertility rate | Close to the replacement level of about 2.1 children per woman | The best single index of fertility control |
| Modern contraceptive prevalence | Over half of women currently using a modern method | Measures the programme's reach |
| Unmet need for family planning | About a tenth of married women who wish to delay or stop | The demand the programme has not yet met |
Methods of contraception
| Class | Methods | Durability and effectiveness | Points for counselling |
|---|---|---|---|
| Spacing - hormonal | Oral contraceptive pills (combined oestrogen-progestin, low dose); injectable progestogen (depot medroxyprogesterone acetate every three months); implants | Over 99% with correct and consistent use; return to fertility is prompt for pills, delayed for injectables | Oestrogen contraindications: smoking over 35, hypertension, thromboembolism history, breast cancer, migraine with aura |
| Spacing - intrauterine device | Copper-bearing device (Cu-T 380A), placed within 10 minutes of placental delivery or in the first weeks postpartum, up to ten years' duration | Over 99% effective without the user remembering a dose | Protects against ectopic and endometrial cancer; not against sexually transmitted infection |
| Spacing - barrier | Male and female condoms | About 85-98% effective in practice — use errors are the whole story | The only method that also protects against sexually transmitted infection (dual protection) |
| Spacing - other | Centchroman (the non-steroidal pill taken twice weekly for three months, then weekly); emergency contraception (levonorgestrel within 72 hours of unprotected sex) | Centchroman is a safe non-hormonal pill; emergency contraception is the rescue, not a routine | Emergency pills must be taken early to work, and they carry no protection later in the cycle |
| Terminal (permanent) | Female sterilisation (minilap — the camp approach — or laparoscopic); male sterilisation (no-scalpel vasectomy) | Over 99% and permanent | Vasectomy is simpler, safer and cheaper than tubectomy, needs no general anaesthesia and does not carry the surgical site of an abdominal incision — and is never to be presented as affecting virility |
NoteGATHER is the counselling sequence used in the family welfare programme: Greet, Ask (about children and wishes), Tell (the options and their properties), Help (choose a method), Explain (how to use it), Return (a follow-up visit). 'Return' is the step most often omitted, and it is the one that keeps a woman on a method and returns her for the next spacing decision.
A mother of three delivered yesterday. In GATHER: Greet; Ask — 'you have three daughters, would you like more? when?'; Tell — the spacing methods she can start today, including a post-placental insertion and the pill after three weeks, and the terminal options; Help — she chooses a Cu-T; Explain — the insertion is painless at this point, bleeding may increase at first, and the threads are checked by the ASHA; Return — visit day 3 for bleeding, and day 42 for the postnatal visit.
The population policy context
India's programme has passed through three phases: the clinic-based approach of the 1950s, the target-driven camp approach of the 1970s — discredited by its coercion during the Emergency — and since 1996 the target-free approach, in which the programme measures itself by the demand it meets rather than by the numbers it performs. The National Population Policy 2000 set the goal of TFR at replacement level by 2010 (with unmet need as the priority metric), and the follow-on emphasis is on the quality and coverage of reproductive and child health services — RCH-II — rather than on sterilisation statistics alone.
NoteThe modern programme's three practical demands are unmet need, quality of care, and male participation: a programme with a low unmet need but poor service quality has met demand on paper only, and vasectomy — cheap, safe and effective — remains the most under-used method in the basket.
Common mistakes
Watch outRecommending a combined oral contraceptive to a woman over 35 who smokes, or to one with hypertension, a history of thromboembolism or breast cancer. Those are the oestrogen contraindications; the counsel for her is an intrauterine device, an injectable, centchroman or a barrier.
Watch outQuoting condoms as a barrier against pregnancy only. The condom is the only method in the basket that also interrupts sexually transmitted infections, which is why family planning counselling must present dual protection — contraception and the condom — rather than an implicit either/or.
Watch outConfusing the crude birth rate with the fertility. The crude birth rate is births per 1,000 of the whole population and is sensitive to the age structure; the total fertility rate is births per woman through her reproductive years and is the figure that determines population replacement.
Check your understanding
Why does a large age structure allow a country's crude birth rate to fall while its total fertility rate stays above replacement?
A woman of 36 who smokes 10 cigarettes a day asks for 'the pill'. What should you counsel?
What is the GATHER sequence, and why is 'Return' emphasised in family welfare?
Multiple choice
Which method provides protection against both pregnancy and sexually transmitted infection?
A total fertility rate of 2.0 in a country implies:
Which of the following is an appropriate method for a 40-year-old woman who has completed her family and wants a permanent method?